Prescrire Int. 2016 Dec;25(177):285-288.
About 50% of patients with meta- static or inoperable melanoma carry a tumour with BRAF V600 mutation.The drug of first choice for these patients is vemurafenib, a BRAF inhibitor, which appears to prolong survival by a few months. Dabrafenib is a vemurafenib me-too with a slightly different known profile of adverse effects. Trametinib, a MEK inhibitor, is now authorised in the European Union for use in this setting, either as monotherapy or in combination with dabrafenib (marketed by the same company). Trametinib monotherapy has not been compared to BRAF inhibitor monotherapy. In a randomised, unblinded trial versus cytotoxic drugs in 322 patients, the median survival time did not differ statistically between the groups (15.6 versus 11.3 months; p = 0.09), but 65% of patients in the chemotherapy group received trametinib after disease pro- gression, making it more difficult to detect a difference between the groups. In an unblinded randomised controlled trial in 704 patients who had never received treatment for metastatic or inoperable disease, the trametinib + dabrafenib combination prolonged median survival by about 8 months more than vemurafenib. In another double-blind randomised controlled trial in 423 patients, median survival was about 6 months longer with trametinib + dabrafenib than with placebo + dabrafenib. The trametinib+ dabrafenibcombination was poorly effective after BRAF inhibitor failure in non-comparative trials including a few dozen patients in which the only endpoint was tumour response. Trametinib has many adverse effects, some of which can be life-threatening, such as heart failure, deep vein thrombosis, bleeding (including intracranial haemorrhage), neutropenia, and gastrointestinal perforation. Trametinib also causes retinal disorders and pneumonitis. Combining trametinib with dabrafenib reduces the risk of hyperkeratosis and skin cancer associated with dabrafenib, but increases the frequency of fever (including very high fever). Trametinib interactions mainly involve additive effects or antagonism. In practice, when a patient with metastatic or inoperable BRAF V600-positive melanoma is willing to accept the significant toxicity of trametinib in the hope of gaining several extra months of life, the trametinib + dabrafenib combination is a first-line option.
约50%的转移性或不可切除性黑色素瘤患者携带BRAF V600突变的肿瘤。这些患者的首选药物是维莫非尼,一种BRAF抑制剂,它似乎能使生存期延长几个月。达拉非尼是维莫非尼的仿制药,其已知的不良反应谱略有不同。曲美替尼是一种MEK抑制剂,目前已在欧盟获批用于这种情况,可作为单药治疗或与达拉非尼联合使用(由同一家公司销售)。曲美替尼单药治疗尚未与BRAF抑制剂单药治疗进行比较。在一项针对322名患者与细胞毒性药物的随机、非盲试验中,两组的中位生存时间在统计学上没有差异(15.6个月对11.3个月;p = 0.09),但化疗组65%的患者在疾病进展后接受了曲美替尼治疗,这使得更难检测出两组之间的差异。在一项针对704名从未接受过转移性或不可切除性疾病治疗的患者的非盲随机对照试验中,曲美替尼+达拉非尼联合用药比维莫非尼使中位生存期延长了约8个月。在另一项针对423名患者的双盲随机对照试验中,曲美替尼+达拉非尼组的中位生存期比安慰剂+达拉非尼组长约6个月。在包括几十名患者的非对照试验中,BRAF抑制剂治疗失败后,曲美替尼+达拉非尼联合用药效果不佳,这些试验中唯一的终点是肿瘤反应。曲美替尼有许多不良反应,其中一些可能危及生命,如心力衰竭、深静脉血栓形成、出血(包括颅内出血)、中性粒细胞减少和胃肠道穿孔。曲美替尼还会引起视网膜疾病和肺炎。曲美替尼与达拉非尼联合使用可降低与达拉非尼相关的角化过度和皮肤癌风险,但会增加发热(包括高热)的频率。曲美替尼的相互作用主要涉及相加作用或拮抗作用。实际上,当一名转移性或不可切除性BRAF V600阳性黑色素瘤患者愿意接受曲美替尼的显著毒性以期望多获得几个月的生命时,曲美替尼+达拉非尼联合用药是一线选择。