a Independent researcher and editor, formerly Department of Field Activities, Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education , Chicago , IL , USA.
b Division of Epidemiology and Public Health, School of Medicine, University of Nottingham , Nottingham , UK.
Med Teach. 2019 Apr;41(4):398-402. doi: 10.1080/0142159X.2019.1567912. Epub 2019 Feb 14.
We examined studies of the clinical learning environment from the fields of sociology and organizational culture to (i) offer insight into how workplace culture has informed research on postgraduate trainee learning and professional development; (ii) highlight limitations of the literature; and (iii) suggest practical ways to apply sociocultural concepts to challenges in the learning environment. Concepts were explored by participants at a consensus conference in October 2018. We identified three enduring foci for research using a sociocultural lens: the hidden curriculum, exploration of medical errors, and the impact of time pressures on the relational nature of clinical education. Limitations included the lower value attributed to informal learning and a pejorative valuation of the hidden curriculum; and disconnect between practices in clinical settings and the priorities of the larger organization. Research on the learning environment using a sociocultural lens suggest workplace goals, norms and practices determined which learners engage in learning-relevant activities, to what extent, and the degree of guidance provided, with these factors creating "tacit" curricula that may support or compete with formal learning goals. We close with guidance on how sociocultural constructs could inform research to improve the learning environment.
我们研究了社会学和组织文化领域关于临床学习环境的研究,(i)深入了解工作场所文化如何影响研究生学习和专业发展的研究;(ii)突出文献的局限性;(iii)并提出将社会文化概念应用于学习环境挑战的实际方法。2018 年 10 月,与会者在共识会议上探讨了这些概念。我们使用社会文化视角确定了三个持久的研究焦点:隐性课程、医疗错误的探索以及时间压力对临床教育关系性质的影响。局限性包括对非正式学习的重视程度较低,以及对隐性课程的贬义评价;以及临床环境中的实践与更大组织的优先事项之间的脱节。使用社会文化视角研究学习环境表明,工作场所的目标、规范和实践决定了哪些学习者参与相关学习活动,以及参与的程度和提供的指导程度,这些因素形成了“隐性”课程,可能支持或与正式学习目标竞争。最后,我们就如何通过社会文化结构为改善学习环境提供信息提出了指导。