Global and Women's Health, Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Cult Health Sex. 2020 Jan;22(1):64-80. doi: 10.1080/13691058.2019.1574029. Epub 2019 Feb 22.
Female genital cosmetic surgery (FGCS) is increasingly popular. Medical organisations report concern about adverse outcomes and inadequate clinical indications. Given the Internet's role in health decisions, we aimed to discover what was being communicated about FGCS on Australian provider websites. Thematic analysis of 31 prominent websites identified six themes: seeking aesthetic perfection; resisting natural diversity; gaining from FGCS; indications for surgery; a simple procedure; and ethical practice. Desirable vulvas were represented as 'neat' and 'youthful'. Sites promoted a discourse in which to be 'feminine' means having no visible sex organs, consistent with the historical repression of women's sexuality. FGCS was constructed as a simple and empowering solution, improving women's comfort, hygiene, self-esteem and sexual relationships. The apparent primary concern was commercial. Attention was rarely paid to ethics. Sites reinforced women's responsibility to strive for aesthetic perfection, implied that vulvar diversity is pathological, made unfounded claims for the benefits of FGCS and downplayed adverse consequences. Findings have implications for public health and medical authorities in countries where FGCS is practised and advertised. Enforcing the first do no harm principle would reduce websites' capacity to promote discourses and practices that damage women's bodies and wellbeing.
女性生殖器整形手术(FGCS)越来越受欢迎。医疗组织报告称,对不良后果和临床指征不足表示担忧。鉴于互联网在健康决策中的作用,我们旨在发现澳大利亚供应商网站上关于 FGCS 的信息。对 31 个知名网站的主题分析确定了六个主题:追求美学完美;抵制自然多样性;从 FGCS 中获益;手术指征;简单的程序;和伦理实践。理想的外阴被描述为“整洁”和“年轻”。网站宣传了一种话语,即要有“女性气质”意味着没有可见的性器官,这与历史上对女性性的压抑相一致。FGCS 被构建为一种简单而赋权的解决方案,可以提高女性的舒适度、卫生、自尊和性关系。显然,主要关注点是商业性的。很少关注伦理问题。网站强化了女性追求美学完美的责任,暗示外阴多样性是病理性的,对 FGCS 的好处提出了毫无根据的主张,并淡化了不良后果。这些发现对 FGCS 实施和宣传的国家的公共卫生和医疗当局具有影响。执行不伤害第一原则将减少网站宣传损害妇女身体和健康的话语和实践的能力。