Zuidberg Matthijs, Bettman Matthijs, Aarts Lhj, Sjerps Marjan, Kokshoorn Bas
Crime Scene Investigation, Specialist Services and Expertise Division, Netherlands Forensic Institute, P.O. Box 24044, 2490 AA The Hague, the Netherlands.
Biological Traces Division, Netherlands Forensic Institute, P.O. Box 24044, 2490 AA The Hague, the Netherlands; Forensic Science, Hogeschool van Amsterdam, P.O. Box 1025, 1000 BA Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Sci Justice. 2019 Mar;59(2):153-161. doi: 10.1016/j.scijus.2018.10.002. Epub 2018 Oct 10.
Sampling strategy is one of the deciding factors in DNA typing success rates. Small amounts of bodily fluid traces and (skin) contact traces are currently not visualized in standard forensic practice. Trace recovery is usually based on the information available in a particular case and on the experience and 'forensic common sense' applied by the trace recovery expert. Interactions between an offender and a victim may have characteristic features, resulting in specific trace patterns. Understanding these interactions, and their resulting trace patterns, might improve crime related trace recovery as well as DNA typing success rates. In this study, we examined the interactions between offender and victim when a body has been relocated from one position/location to another. The contact between the hands of the offender and the body of the victim was visualized using a fluorescent dye in a lotion that was applied to the hands of the individual undertaking the relocation. The contact locations were scored and patterns were analyzed based on both victim and offender characteristics (height, weight, age, gender). The resulting patterns were compared to current trace recovery practices in the Netherlands. The results of this large-scale study facilitate evidence-based sampling supporting both investigative and evaluative forensic examinations.
采样策略是DNA分型成功率的决定性因素之一。目前,在标准法医实践中,少量体液痕迹和(皮肤)接触痕迹无法可视化。痕迹提取通常基于特定案件中的可用信息以及痕迹提取专家所运用的经验和“法医常识”。犯罪者与受害者之间的互动可能具有特征性,从而产生特定的痕迹模式。了解这些互动及其产生的痕迹模式,可能会提高与犯罪相关的痕迹提取以及DNA分型成功率。在本研究中,我们研究了尸体从一个位置/地点转移到另一个位置时犯罪者与受害者之间的互动。通过将一种含有荧光染料的洗剂涂抹在进行尸体转移者的手上,使犯罪者的手与受害者身体之间的接触得以可视化。根据受害者和犯罪者的特征(身高、体重、年龄、性别)对接触位置进行评分并分析模式。将所得模式与荷兰目前的痕迹提取实践进行比较。这项大规模研究的结果有助于为支持调查性和评估性法医检验的循证采样提供依据。