Lloyd Jacob, Pinto Ashna Maria, Nair Shoba, Tarey Subhash
Department of Pain and Palliative Medicine, St. John's Medical College, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India.
Indian J Palliat Care. 2019 Jan-Mar;25(1):84-91. doi: 10.4103/IJPC.IJPC_161_18.
Stroke is the development of a focal neurological disturbance lasting >24 h, of vascular origin. In India, stroke is one of the leading causes of morbidity and mortality. Most stroke patients, during their duration of treatment and posthospitalization, want relief of suffering, a sense of control and minimized burden on the family.
The aim of this study is to describe treating doctors' perspectives on the palliative needs of stroke patients in India.
This qualitative study was conducted at a tertiary care hospital in South India. A total of 17 doctors involved in the care of stroke patients were interviewed, using an interview guide. The interviews were audio recorded simultaneously. The audio recording was transcribed verbatim, and the data were coded using a grounded theory approach. An inductive approach using thematic analysis was used to manually analyze the data.
Eight themes emerged. (1) Functional disability: loss of independence due to immobility, speech deficits, visual disturbances, feeding difficulties, and incontinence cause immense distress. (2) Physical burden: pain in the form of central poststroke pain, periarthritic shoulder, psychogenic pain, and various sequela of chronic bed bound state like bed sores and pneumonia add to the burden. (3) Psychological needs: depression is common in stroke patients along with other psychological issues such as anxiety, agitation, apathetic state, and behavioral disturbances (4) Social issues: Cost of treatment of stroke patients coupled with their loss of employment leads to huge economic burden. They also face abandonment by children or spouse, in all sections of socioeconomic strata. (5) Caregiver burden: caregiver has a major role in a setting of stroke and in the long-term affects all domains of their lives, compromising their psychological and physical health. (6) Counseling-an unmet need: counseling is particularly important in a setting of stroke for the patient as well as the caregivers and results in a better patient outcome. However, clinicians expressed that it was inadequate due to the huge patient load, time constraints, and lack of effective counseling skills. (7) Spiritual needs: few clinicians stated that existential distress and spiritual struggle are seen in debilitated stroke victims and are often unaddressed. (8) Issues at the end of life care: patients with massive stroke, multiple comorbidities, and poor rehabilitative potential requires end of life care.
From the interviews of the clinicians, we can conclude that care of a stroke patient is more than medical management and rehabilitation, as several other aspects of the patient's life are affected by the condition. The quality of life aspect has to be looked upon as an area that requires active intervention in a setting of stroke. Physical disabilities were viewed as the most significant factor in reducing the quality of life. Spiritual needs have a low priority in comparison to other physical needs. Due to high patient load and time constraints, many of the needs are unaddressed. Two important areas where palliative medicine has a major role in a setting of stroke are counseling and alleviating caregiver burden. However, referral of stroke patients to palliative medicine is low and further research to identify barriers to specialist palliative care of stroke patients will help in promoting the referrals to palliative medicine.
中风是指由血管源性病因导致的局灶性神经功能障碍持续超过24小时。在印度,中风是发病和死亡的主要原因之一。大多数中风患者在治疗期间和出院后,都希望减轻痛苦、获得掌控感并减轻家庭负担。
本研究旨在描述印度治疗医生对中风患者姑息治疗需求的看法。
这项定性研究在印度南部的一家三级护理医院进行。使用访谈指南,共对17名参与中风患者护理的医生进行了访谈。访谈同时进行录音。录音逐字转录,数据采用扎根理论方法进行编码。使用主题分析的归纳方法对数据进行人工分析。
出现了八个主题。(1)功能残疾:因行动不便、言语缺陷、视觉障碍、进食困难和大小便失禁导致的独立性丧失会造成巨大痛苦。(2)身体负担:中风后中枢性疼痛、肩周炎、心因性疼痛以及长期卧床导致的各种后遗症(如褥疮和肺炎)等形式的疼痛增加了负担。(3)心理需求:中风患者中抑郁症很常见,同时还伴有其他心理问题,如焦虑、躁动、冷漠状态和行为障碍。(4)社会问题:中风患者的治疗费用加上失业导致巨大的经济负担。在社会经济各阶层中,他们还面临被子女或配偶抛弃的情况。(5)照顾者负担:照顾者在中风患者的护理中起着重要作用,长期来看会影响他们生活的各个方面,损害他们的身心健康。(6)咨询——未满足的需求:咨询对中风患者及其照顾者尤为重要,能带来更好的患者治疗效果。然而,临床医生表示,由于患者数量众多、时间限制以及缺乏有效的咨询技能,咨询服务不足。(7)精神需求:少数临床医生表示,虚弱的中风患者存在生存痛苦和精神挣扎,且往往未得到解决。(8)临终关怀问题:大面积中风、多种合并症且康复潜力差的患者需要临终关怀。
通过对临床医生的访谈,我们可以得出结论,中风患者的护理不仅仅是医疗管理和康复,因为患者生活的其他几个方面也会受到该疾病的影响。生活质量方面必须被视为中风情况下需要积极干预的领域。身体残疾被视为降低生活质量的最重要因素。与其他身体需求相比,精神需求的优先级较低。由于患者数量众多和时间限制,许多需求未得到满足。姑息医学在中风护理中发挥重要作用的两个重要领域是咨询和减轻照顾者负担。然而,中风患者转介至姑息医学的比例较低,进一步研究确定中风患者专科姑息治疗的障碍将有助于促进转介至姑息医学。