Joseph Hayley, Sullivan Sarah, Wood Peter, Melrose Wayne, Taleo Fasihah, Graves Patricia
The Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research, Division of Population Health and Immunity, Melbourne, VIC 3052, Australia.
Department of Medical Biology, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC 3052, Australia.
Trop Med Infect Dis. 2019 Mar 8;4(1):45. doi: 10.3390/tropicalmed4010045.
As the prevalence of lymphatic filariasis declines, it becomes crucial to adequately eliminate residual areas of endemicity and implement surveillance. To this end, serological assays have been developed, including the Bm14 Filariasis CELISA which recommends a specific optical density cut-off level. We used mixture modelling to assess positive cut-offs of Bm14 serology in children in Vanuatu using historical OD (Optical Density) ELISA values collected from a transmission assessment survey (2005) and a targeted child survey (2008). Mixture modelling is a statistical technique using probability distributions to identify subpopulations of positive and negative results (absolute cut-off value) and an 80% indeterminate range around the absolute cut-off (80% cut-off). Depending on programmatic choices, utilizing the lower 80% cut-off ensures the inclusion of all likely positives, however with the trade-off of lower specificity. For 2005, country-wide antibody prevalence estimates varied from 6.4% (previous cut-off) through 9.0% (absolute cut-off) to 17.3% (lower 80% cut-off). This corroborated historical evidence of hotspots in Pentecost Island in Penama province. For 2008, there were no differences in the prevalence rates using any of the thresholds. In conclusion, mixture modelling is a powerful tool that allows closer monitoring of residual transmission spots and these findings supported additional monitoring which was conducted in Penama in later years. Utilizing a statistical data-based cut-off, as opposed to a universal cut-off, may help guide program decisions that are better suited to the national program.
随着淋巴丝虫病患病率下降,充分消除地方病残留区域并开展监测变得至关重要。为此,已开发出血清学检测方法,包括推荐特定光密度临界值水平的Bm14丝虫病夹心酶联免疫吸附测定法(CELISA)。我们利用混合模型,通过从传播评估调查(2005年)和目标儿童调查(2008年)收集的历史光密度(OD)酶联免疫吸附测定值,评估瓦努阿图儿童Bm14血清学的阳性临界值。混合模型是一种统计技术,使用概率分布来识别阳性和阴性结果的亚群(绝对临界值)以及绝对临界值周围80%的不确定范围(80%临界值)。根据项目选择,采用较低的80%临界值可确保纳入所有可能的阳性结果,但会以较低的特异性为代价。2005年,全国抗体患病率估计值从6.4%(先前临界值)到9.0%(绝对临界值)再到17.3%(较低的80%临界值)不等。这证实了彭纳马省圣灵岛存在热点地区的历史证据。2008年,使用任何阈值的患病率均无差异。总之,混合模型是一种强大的工具,可更密切地监测残留传播点,这些发现支持了随后几年在彭纳马进行的额外监测。采用基于统计数据的临界值而非通用临界值,可能有助于指导更适合国家项目的项目决策。