GSK, Wavre, Belgium.
GSK, Uxbridge, UK.
BMJ Open. 2019 May 5;9(5):e025553. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-025553.
In 2013, the herpes zoster (HZ) immunisation programme was introduced in the UK, recommending vaccination of adults 70 years of age (YOA) with the zoster vaccine live (ZVL), the only vaccine available at the time. The recently approved adjuvanted recombinant zoster vaccine (RZV) has a substantially different clinical profile that may offer additional benefits.This study aimed to 1) assess the public health impact (PHI) of introducing RZV in the UK compared with the current vaccination strategy and 2) explore via scenario analyses the optimal age group of vaccination in terms of PHI.
A previously developed health economic model was adapted to the UK setting.
Calculations were based on efficacy data from pivotal clinical trials, HZ incidence and postherpetic neuralgia (PHN) probability from a UK study and HZ-associated complication rates from published literature.
The base-case population considered a 2018-projected UK vaccination cohort of individuals 70 YOA.
Vaccination with ZVL or RZV, assuming a first-dose coverage of 48.3% for both vaccines and 70% compliance for the second dose of RZV.
Outcomes included reduction of HZ and PHN cases, complications and the use of healthcare resources over a life-time horizon. The impact of coverage and second-dose compliance was also explored.
Compared with no vaccination, RZV would lead to a reduction of 30 262 HZ and 5409 PHN cases while ZVL would lead to a reduction of 7909 HZ and 3567 PHN cases. The number needed to vaccinate to prevent 1 HZ case is 12 with RZV and 45 with ZVL. The highest PHI with RZV could be achieved in individuals 60 or 65 YOA.
Under the model assumptions, RZV is predicted to avert more HZ and PHN cases compared with ZVL. Results were robust under different scenario and sensitivity analyses.
2013 年,在英国引入了带状疱疹(HZ)免疫计划,建议为 70 岁(YOA)的成年人接种带状疱疹活疫苗(ZVL),这是当时唯一可用的疫苗。最近批准的佐剂重组带状疱疹疫苗(RZV)具有明显不同的临床特征,可能会带来额外的益处。本研究旨在 1)评估在英国引入 RZV 与当前疫苗接种策略相比的公共卫生影响(PHI),2)通过情景分析探索在 PHI 方面最佳的接种年龄组。
对先前开发的健康经济模型进行了调整,以适应英国的情况。
计算基于来自关键临床试验的疗效数据、来自英国研究的 HZ 发病率和带状疱疹后神经痛(PHN)概率以及来自已发表文献的 HZ 相关并发症率。
基础病例人群考虑了 2018 年预计的英国疫苗接种队列,其中包括 70 岁的个体。
接种 ZVL 或 RZV,假设两种疫苗的首剂覆盖率为 48.3%,RZV 的第二剂覆盖率为 70%。
与不接种疫苗相比,RZV 将导致 HZ 和 PHN 病例减少 30262 例和 5409 例,而 ZVL 将导致 HZ 减少 7909 例和 PHN 减少 3567 例。预防 1 例 HZ 病例需要接种的人数为 12 例,用 RZV 接种,用 ZVL 接种 45 例。RZV 可实现的最高 PHI 是在 60 岁或 65 岁的个体中。
在模型假设下,RZV 预计将比 ZVL 预防更多的 HZ 和 PHN 病例。在不同的情景和敏感性分析下,结果都是稳健的。