Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Aarhus University Hospital, Palle Juul-Jensens Boulevard 99, DK-8200, Aarhus N, Denmark.
Department of Clinical Medicine, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark.
BMC Fam Pract. 2019 Jun 1;20(1):75. doi: 10.1186/s12875-019-0970-3.
The national guideline for sore throat, endorsed by the Danish Society of General Medicine, recommends the use of the modified Centor score and streptococcal rapid antigen detection test to guide diagnosis and treatment of sore throat. The aim was to investigate Danish general practitioners (GPs) routine management of sore throat patients with a focus on the modalities used and adherence to the guideline.
A cross-sectional study. GPs in the Central Denmark Region answered an online questionnaire in October 2017. The main outcome measure was modalities used in the management of sore throat patients.
In total, 266 of 500 (53%) GPs answered the survey. Ten percent of participants were adherent or almost adherent to the guideline, while 82% of GPs added one or more extra modalities (general clinical assessment (67%), biochemical parameters (48%), and throat swabs for bacterial culture (18%)) to differentiate viral and bacterial etiology. Sixty-five percent of participants used the Centor Score or modified Centor Score, 96% of GPs used a streptococcal rapid antigen detection test, and all GPs chose narrow-spectrum penicillin as the first-line antibiotic. The most common reasons for non-adherence to the guideline were greater confidence in the clinical assessment (39%), time pressure (33%), and difficulty recalling the guideline (19%).
Danish GPs rarely adhere to the recommended sore throat management guideline, but use various combinations of different modalities in the assessment of bacterial infection. This practice may increase antibiotic prescription rates.
丹麦普通医学学会认可的咽喉痛国家指南建议使用改良的 Centor 评分和链球菌快速抗原检测试验来指导咽喉痛的诊断和治疗。目的是调查丹麦全科医生(GP)对咽喉痛患者的常规管理,重点关注所使用的方法和对指南的依从性。
一项横断面研究。2017 年 10 月,丹麦中部地区的全科医生在线回答了一份问卷。主要结局指标是用于管理咽喉痛患者的方法。
共有 500 名全科医生中的 266 名(53%)回答了调查。10%的参与者遵守或几乎遵守指南,而 82%的全科医生添加了一种或多种额外的方法(一般临床评估(67%)、生化参数(48%)和细菌培养的咽喉拭子(18%))来区分病毒和细菌病因。65%的参与者使用 Centor 评分或改良的 Centor 评分,96%的全科医生使用链球菌快速抗原检测试验,所有全科医生都选择窄谱青霉素作为一线抗生素。不遵守指南的最常见原因是对临床评估更有信心(39%)、时间压力(33%)和难以回忆起指南(19%)。
丹麦全科医生很少遵守推荐的咽喉痛管理指南,但在评估细菌感染时使用各种不同方法的组合。这种做法可能会增加抗生素的处方率。