Department of Paediatrics, Fribourg Hospital HFR, Fribourg, Switzerland / Faculty of Science and Medicine, University of Fribourg, Switzerland.
Department of Paediatrics, Fribourg Hospital HFR, Fribourg, Switzerland / Centre médical de La Chapelle, Geneva, Switzerland.
Swiss Med Wkly. 2019 Jun 16;149:w20091. doi: 10.4414/smw.2019.20091. eCollection 2019 Jun 3.
In Switzerland, complementary medicine (CM) is officially recognised within the healthcare system and mainly practised in an integrative manner, in conjunction with conventional medicine. As in other countries, there is high demand for and use of CM with children. However, there has so far been no research into the attitude towards, training in and offer of CM among paediatricians in Switzerland. Our study addresses this gap by investigating these topics with an online survey of paediatricians in Switzerland.
We conducted a national online survey using a 19-item, self-reporting questionnaire among all ordinary and junior members of the Swiss Society of Paediatrics (SSP). A comparison of the study sample with the population of all paediatricians registered with the Swiss Medical Association (FMH) allowed an assessment of the survey’s representativeness. The data analysis was performed on the overall group level as well as for predefined subgroups (e.g. sex, age, language, workplace and professional experience).
1890 paediatricians were approached and 640, from all parts of Switzerland, responded to the survey (response rate 34%). Two thirds of respondents were female, were aged between 35 and 55 years, trained as paediatric generalist and worked in a practice. Apart from young paediatricians in training, the study sample was representative of all Swiss paediatricians. 23% had attended training in CM, most frequently in phytotherapy, homeopathy, acupuncture/traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and anthroposophic medicine. 65% were interested in CM courses and training. 16% provide CM services to their patients and almost all paediatricians (97%) are asked by patients/parents about CM therapies. More than half of the responding paediatricians use CM for themselves or their families. 42% were willing to contribute to paediatric CM research.
In a representative sample of paediatricians in Switzerland, their personal attitude towards CM is positive, emphasised by great interest in CM training, a willingness to contribute to CM research and a high rate of paediatricians who use CM for themselves and their families. In contrast, the percentage of paediatricians offering CM is currently rather low despite strong demand for CM for children. This study provides key pointers for the future development of complementary and integrative medicine for children in Switzerland.
在瑞士,补充医学(CM)在医疗体系中得到正式认可,主要以与传统医学相结合的综合方式实施。与其他国家一样,瑞士对儿童补充医学的需求和使用也很高。然而,目前尚无关于瑞士儿科医生对补充医学的态度、培训和提供情况的研究。我们通过对瑞士儿科医生进行在线调查,研究了这些主题,从而填补了这一空白。
我们使用瑞士儿科协会(SSP)所有普通和初级成员的 19 项自我报告问卷,对瑞士全国的儿科医生进行了一项在线调查。通过将研究样本与瑞士医学协会(FMH)注册的所有儿科医生的人群进行比较,可以评估调查的代表性。数据分析在总体组和预定义子组(例如性别、年龄、语言、工作场所和专业经验)上进行。
共联系了 1890 名儿科医生,来自瑞士各地的 640 名儿科医生对调查做出了回应(回应率为 34%)。三分之二的受访者为女性,年龄在 35 至 55 岁之间,接受过儿科全科医生培训,并在诊所工作。除了年轻的受训儿科医生外,研究样本代表了所有瑞士儿科医生。23%的人参加过补充医学培训,最常见的是植物疗法、顺势疗法、针灸/中医(TCM)和人智学医学。65%的人对补充医学课程和培训感兴趣。16%的人向患者提供补充医学服务,几乎所有的儿科医生(97%)都被患者/家长询问过补充医学治疗方法。超过一半的回应儿科医生自己或家人使用补充医学。42%的人愿意为儿科补充医学研究做出贡献。
在瑞士具有代表性的儿科医生样本中,他们对补充医学的个人态度是积极的,这突出体现在他们对补充医学培训的极大兴趣、愿意为补充医学研究做出贡献以及很大比例的儿科医生自己或家人使用补充医学。相比之下,尽管儿童对补充医学的需求很高,但目前提供补充医学的儿科医生比例相当低。这项研究为瑞士儿童补充和整合医学的未来发展提供了关键要点。