Malau-Aduli Bunmi S, Preston Robyn, Adu Mary, Alele Faith, Gratani Monica, Drovandi Aaron, Heslop Ian
College of Medicine and Dentistry, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland QLD 4811, Australia.
College of Medicine and Dentistry, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland QLD 4811, Australia.
Curr Pharm Teach Learn. 2019 Jun;11(6):571-579. doi: 10.1016/j.cptl.2019.02.020. Epub 2019 Mar 21.
Outcomes-based education requires active student learning with assessment strategies that foster deep approaches to learning, which are often influenced by students' perceptions of assessment. We aimed to investigate the perceptions of pharmacy students at an Australian university about their experiences of assessment and its impact on their learning.
A mixed-methods study was conducted involving a self-administered questionnaire and semi-structured focus groups. Descriptive statistics were used to rate the perceived value of different assessment tools and confirmed by themes arising from the focus groups. Examination results over a five-year period were also collated to assess congruence between perceptions and academic performance.
From the 123 questionnaire and nine focus group participants, short-answer questions were the most positively-received form of assessment due to students being able to demonstrate and receive marks for partial knowledge. Multiple-choice questions received mixed response as they were cited as being useful in assessing student knowledge but potentially difficult to interpret/answer correctly. Reflective pieces received the lowest ratings and were considered the least beneficial. Key identified themes were ensuring quality assurance of assessment processes, use of authentic assessment, timely feedback, and appropriate match between workload and assessment weightings. Overall, there was congruence between students' exam scores and their perceptions of the different assessment types.
Strategic planning and delivery of correctly-weighted authentic assessments with the provision of constructive feedback are key elements for active engagement of students and achievement of life-long learning outcomes.
基于成果的教育要求学生积极参与学习,并采用能促进深度学习方法的评估策略,而这通常受学生对评估的看法影响。我们旨在调查澳大利亚一所大学药学专业学生对其评估经历及其对学习影响的看法。
开展了一项混合方法研究,包括一份自填式问卷和半结构化焦点小组。使用描述性统计来评估不同评估工具的感知价值,并通过焦点小组产生的主题进行确认。还整理了五年期间的考试成绩,以评估看法与学业成绩之间的一致性。
在123名问卷参与者和9名焦点小组参与者中,简答题是最受好评的评估形式,因为学生能够展示部分知识并获得分数。多项选择题的反馈不一,因为它们被认为有助于评估学生知识,但可能难以正确解释/回答。反思性文章得分最低,被认为最没有益处。确定的关键主题包括确保评估过程的质量保证、使用真实评估、及时反馈以及工作量与评估权重之间的适当匹配。总体而言,学生的考试成绩与他们对不同评估类型的看法之间存在一致性。
进行战略规划并提供正确加权的真实评估,并给予建设性反馈,是促使学生积极参与并实现终身学习成果的关键要素。