Wiener R Constance, Dwibedi Nilanjana, Shen Chan, Findley Patricia A, Sambamoorthi Usha
Department of Dental Practice and Rural Health, School of Dentistry, 104A Health Sciences Addition, P. O. Box 9415, West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV 26506-9448, USA.
Department of Pharmaceutical Systems and Policy, West Virginia University School of Pharmacy, Robert C. Byrd Health Sciences Center [North], P.O. Box 9510, Morgantown, WV 26506-9510, USA.
Adv Public Health. 2018;2018. doi: 10.1155/2018/1893562. Epub 2018 Jun 26.
The purpose of this study was to determine the concordance of self-reported responses to oral health questions versus clinically evaluated recommended need for oral healthcare by calibrated dentists to determine usefulness of the questions for epidemiological studies. We additionally examined other factors associated with concordant self-reports versus clinical evaluations.
We used a cross-sectional study design with 4,205 participants, ages 30 years and above, who had complete oral health self-perception data and dental referral data in the NHANES 2013-14. Calibrated dentists completed clinical oral healthcare assessments. The assessments were dichotomized to (1) recommendation for immediate care and (2) routine oral health care. Self-reported oral health needs were measured with 6 items (an overall oral health self-perception question, oral pain within the previous year, impact on job/school, suspected periodontal disease, tooth appearance, and tooth mobility). The key item of interest was the overall oral health self-perception question.
Concordance with clinically evaluated recommended need for oral healthcare varied from 52.0% (oral pain) to 65.4% (overall oral health self-perception). Many subgroup differences were observed.
The overall self-perception of oral health and the clinical evaluation of oral healthcare need were substantially concordant; other self-reported measures were moderately concordant. This is useful information and points to the need for a minimum set of measures that can provide actionable information and capture the need for clinical dental care.
本研究旨在确定自我报告的口腔健康问题回答与经过校准的牙医临床评估的口腔保健推荐需求之间的一致性,以确定这些问题在流行病学研究中的有用性。我们还研究了与自我报告和临床评估一致相关的其他因素。
我们采用横断面研究设计,纳入了4205名年龄在30岁及以上的参与者,他们在2013 - 2014年美国国家健康与营养检查调查(NHANES)中有完整的口腔健康自我认知数据和牙科转诊数据。经过校准的牙医完成了临床口腔保健评估。评估结果被分为两类:(1)立即护理推荐和(2)常规口腔保健。自我报告的口腔健康需求通过6个项目进行测量(一个总体口腔健康自我认知问题、过去一年中的口腔疼痛、对工作/学校的影响、疑似牙周疾病、牙齿外观和牙齿松动)。感兴趣的关键项目是总体口腔健康自我认知问题。
自我报告与临床评估的口腔保健推荐需求之间的一致性从52.0%(口腔疼痛)到65.4%(总体口腔健康自我认知)不等。观察到许多亚组差异。
口腔健康的总体自我认知与口腔保健需求的临床评估基本一致;其他自我报告的测量结果中度一致。这是有用的信息,表明需要一套最少的测量方法,能够提供可采取行动的信息并反映临床牙科护理的需求。