Tong M J, Co R L, Marci R D, Michaelson P M, Ortega G
Liver Center, Huntington Memorial Hospital, Pasadena, CA 91105.
Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 1988 Feb;9(2):66-71. doi: 10.1086/645787.
We compared the cost of antibody screening and the projected cost for hepatitis B vaccination of antibody-negative individuals at hospitals with "high prevalence" and "low prevalence" rates for hepatitis B virus antibodies among their employees. The use of hepatitis B core antibody for screening and subsequent hepatitis B vaccination of antibody-negative personnel was most cost-effective for hospitals considered to have high prevalence for hepatitis B virus antibodies among its staff, although use of hepatitis B surface antibody in this setting only increased costs by 1.4%. In a hospital with low prevalence for hepatitis B virus antibodies among its staff, use of hepatitis B surface antibody and subsequent vaccination of antibody-negative individuals was the most cost-effective approach, while use of hepatitis B core antibody for the above purposes would have increased costs by 3.4%. The use of both hepatitis B surface antibody and core antibody in either setting followed by immunization was least economical, as costs were increased by 13% and 13.5% respectively. We concluded that hepatitis B core antibody should be used for screening in hospitals with high prevalence for hepatitis B virus antibodies among employees while hepatitis B surface antibody be used for screening in hospitals with low prevalence for hepatitis B virus antibodies among employees. A prediction of high and low prevalence for hepatitis B virus antibodies in hospital personnel may be made by knowledge of the distribution in ethnicity of staff.
我们比较了在员工中乙肝病毒抗体“高流行率”和“低流行率”的医院中,抗体筛查的成本以及抗体阴性个体的乙肝疫苗接种预计成本。对于被认为员工中乙肝病毒抗体流行率高的医院,使用乙肝核心抗体进行筛查并对抗体阴性人员随后接种乙肝疫苗是最具成本效益的,尽管在此情况下使用乙肝表面抗体只会使成本增加1.4%。在员工中乙肝病毒抗体流行率低的医院,使用乙肝表面抗体并对抗体阴性个体随后接种疫苗是最具成本效益的方法,而使用乙肝核心抗体用于上述目的会使成本增加3.4%。在任何一种情况下同时使用乙肝表面抗体和核心抗体随后进行免疫接种是最不经济的,因为成本分别增加了13%和13.5%。我们得出结论,对于员工中乙肝病毒抗体流行率高的医院,应使用乙肝核心抗体进行筛查,而对于员工中乙肝病毒抗体流行率低的医院,应使用乙肝表面抗体进行筛查。通过了解员工的种族分布,可以预测医院人员中乙肝病毒抗体的高流行率和低流行率。