European Topic Centre, University of Malaga, Malaga, Spain.
European Topic Centre, University of Malaga, Malaga, Spain.
J Environ Manage. 2019 Oct 1;247:484-498. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.06.084. Epub 2019 Jun 27.
Environmental studies with Landsat images have revealed many of the problems faced by wetland ecosystem, which are crucial for the conservation of biodiversity and the natural values of our planet. The study of LULC changes in wetlands through remote sensing constantly helps to identify and combat their main environmental threats improving the conservation of these natural habitats. Starting in mid-2015, the Sentinel-2 satellite opens new possibilities in the field of earth observation thanks to its higher spatial, spectral and temporal resolution becoming a powerful source of information for LULC monitoring in wetland areas. However, researchers may ask them selves to what extent Sentinel-2 is an improvement over Landsat 8 for general purposes. This research test if there is a real difference in the quality of the results delivered by both Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 imagery when basic classification methods are applied. The study uses Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 imagery to produce LULC maps in a Mediterranean wetland area applying an object based classification method in order to compare the accuracy and reliability in the surface detected by both satellites. The results show that an object based classification using only the Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 image information, without band indexes or ancillary data, offers very similar results for most LULC classes, being the overall accuracy around 87-88% with slightly better results when using Sentinel-2. Although using Sentinel-2 leads to an increase in file size and processing times, the analysis of certain LULC classes presents an improvement compared to Landsat 8, detecting more linear and small size elements with a better delineation of image features in the classified map. However, these improvements should not underestimate the value of Landsat imagery in the future since both satellites provide high precision information, so they can and should coexist and be used together to increase data availability in order to have the best possible results in remote sensing research.
利用陆地卫星图像进行的环境研究揭示了湿地生态系统面临的许多问题,这些问题对保护生物多样性和地球的自然价值至关重要。通过遥感研究湿地的土地利用/土地覆盖变化,不断有助于识别和应对其主要的环境威胁,从而改善这些自然栖息地的保护。自 2015 年年中以来,Sentinel-2 卫星凭借其更高的空间、光谱和时间分辨率,在地球观测领域开辟了新的可能性,成为湿地地区土地利用/土地覆盖监测的有力信息源。然而,研究人员可能会问自己,Sentinel-2 在一般用途方面相对于 Landsat 8 有多大程度的改进。本研究测试了在应用基本分类方法时,Sentinel-2 和 Landsat 8 图像提供的结果质量是否存在真正的差异。该研究使用 Sentinel-2 和 Landsat 8 图像在一个地中海湿地地区生成土地利用/土地覆盖图,应用基于对象的分类方法,以比较两颗卫星探测到的地表的精度和可靠性。结果表明,仅使用 Sentinel-2 和 Landsat 8 图像信息,不使用波段索引或辅助数据进行基于对象的分类,对于大多数土地利用/土地覆盖类别,提供非常相似的结果,总体精度约为 87-88%,使用 Sentinel-2 时结果略好。虽然使用 Sentinel-2 会导致文件大小和处理时间增加,但与 Landsat 8 相比,某些土地利用/土地覆盖类别的分析有所改进,能够检测到更多线性和小尺寸的元素,并且在分类图中对图像特征的划分更加清晰。然而,这些改进不应低估 Landsat 图像在未来的价值,因为这两颗卫星都提供高精度的信息,因此它们可以并且应该共存并一起使用,以增加数据的可用性,从而在遥感研究中获得尽可能好的结果。