Micali Linda Renata, Matteucci Francesco, Parise Orlando, Tetta Cecilia, Moula Amalia Ioanna, de Jong Monique, Londero Francesco, Gelsomino Sandro
Cardiothoracic Department, Maastricht University Hospital, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
J Card Surg. 2019 Nov;34(11):1297-1304. doi: 10.1111/jocs.14186. Epub 2019 Aug 31.
We investigated neurological events, graft patency, major adverse cardiovascular events (MACEs), and mortality at 1 year following coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) surgery using automated proximal anastomotic devices (APADs) and compared the overall rates with the current literature.
A systematic review of all available reports of APADs use in the literature was conducted. Cumulative incidence and 95% confidence interval (CI) were the main statistical indexes. Nine observational studies encompassing a total of 718 patients were included at the end of the selection process.
The cumulative event rate of neurological complications was 4.8% (lower-upper limits: 2.8-8.0, P < .001; I = 72.907%, P = .002; Egger's test: intercept = -2.47, P = 0.16; Begg and Mazumdar test: τ = -0.20, p = 0.57). Graft patency was 90.5% (80.4 to 95.7, P < .001; I = 76.823%, P = .005; Egger's test: intercept = -3.04, P = .10; Begg and Mazumdar test: τ = -0.67, P = .17). Furthermore, the overall incidence of MACEs was 3.7% (1.3-10.4, P < .001; I = 51.556%, P = .103; Egger's test: intercept = -1.98, P = < .11; Begg and Mazumdar test: τ = -0.67, P = .17). Finally, mortality within 1 year was 5% (3.5-7, P < .001; I = 29.675%, P = .202; Egger's test: intercept = -0.91, P = .62; Begg and Mazumdar test: τ = -0.04, P = .88).
APADs do not seem to be correlated with a reduction of either neurological events or mortality. By contrast, these tools showed satisfactory one-year graft patency and a low incidence of MACEs. Further research on this topic is warranted.
我们研究了使用自动近端吻合装置(APADs)进行冠状动脉旁路移植术(CABG)后1年的神经事件、移植物通畅情况、主要不良心血管事件(MACEs)和死亡率,并将总体发生率与当前文献进行了比较。
对文献中所有关于使用APADs的可用报告进行了系统评价。累积发病率和95%置信区间(CI)是主要的统计指标。在筛选过程结束时,纳入了9项观察性研究,共718例患者。
神经并发症的累积事件发生率为4.8%(下限-上限:2.8-8.0,P <.001;I² = 72.907%,P =.002;Egger检验:截距 = -2.47,P = 0.16;Begg和Mazumdar检验:τ = -0.20,p = 0.57)。移植物通畅率为90.5%(80.4至95.7,P <.001;I² = 76.823%,P =.005;Egger检验:截距 = -3.04,P =.10;Begg和Mazumdar检验:τ = -0.67,P =.17)。此外,MACEs的总体发生率为3.7%(1.3-10.4,P <.001;I² = 51.556%,P =.103;Egger检验:截距 = -1.98,P <.11;Begg和Mazumdar检验:τ = -0.67,P =.17)。最后,1年内的死亡率为5%(3.5-7,P <.001;I² = 29.675%,P =.202;Egger检验:截距 = -0.91,P =.62;Begg和Mazumdar检验:τ = -0.04,P =.88)。
APADs似乎与神经事件或死亡率的降低无关。相比之下,这些工具显示出令人满意的1年移植物通畅率和较低的MACEs发生率。对此主题进行进一步研究是有必要的。