Department of Sociology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, USA.
Department of Sociology, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Demography. 2019 Oct;56(5):1635-1664. doi: 10.1007/s13524-019-00817-y.
This article provides a rich longitudinal portrait of the financial and social resources available in the school districts of high- and low-income students in the United States from 1990 to 2014. Combining multiple publicly available data sources for most school districts in the United States, we document levels and gaps in school district financial resources-total per-pupil expenditures-and social resources-local rates of adult educational attainment, family structure, and adult unemployment-available to the average public school student at a variety of income levels over time. In addition to using eligibility for the National School Lunch Program as a blunt measure of student income, we estimate resource inequalities between income deciles to analyze resource gaps between affluent and poor children. We then examine the relationship between income segregation and resource gaps between the school districts of high- and low-income children. In previous work, the social context of schooling has been a theoretical but unmeasured mechanism through which income segregation may operate to create unequal opportunities for children. Our results show large and, in some cases, growing social resource gaps in the districts of high- and low-income students nationally and provide evidence that these gaps are exacerbated by income segregation. Conversely, per-pupil funding became more compensatory between high- and low-income students' school districts over this period, especially in highly segregated states. However, there are early signs of reversal in this trend. The results provide evidence that school finance reforms have been somewhat effective in reducing the consequences of income segregation on funding inequities, while inequalities in the social context of schooling continue to grow.
本文通过结合美国大部分学区的多个公开数据源,为我们描绘了 1990 年至 2014 年美国高收入和低收入学生所在学区的财务和社会资源的丰富纵向情况。我们记录了学区财政资源(每名学生的总支出)和社会资源(当地成年人受教育程度、家庭结构和成年人失业率)的水平和差距,这些资源是在不同收入水平下的普通公立学校学生在一段时间内可获得的。除了使用国家学校午餐计划的资格作为学生收入的一个粗略衡量标准外,我们还估计了收入十分位数之间的资源不平等,以分析富裕儿童和贫困儿童之间的资源差距。然后,我们研究了收入隔离与贫富学生所在学区之间的资源差距之间的关系。在之前的研究中,学校教育的社会背景一直是一个理论上但未被衡量的机制,通过这个机制,收入隔离可能会对儿童的机会不平等产生影响。我们的研究结果表明,全国范围内高收入和低收入学生所在学区的社会资源差距很大,在某些情况下还在扩大,并提供了证据表明,收入隔离加剧了这些差距。相反,在此期间,高收入和低收入学生所在学区的生均资金差距在逐渐缩小,特别是在高度隔离的州。然而,这种趋势已经出现了逆转的早期迹象。研究结果表明,学校财政改革在一定程度上有效减少了收入隔离对资金不平等的影响,而学校教育的社会背景的不平等仍在继续扩大。