Okasha Ahmed
Director, WHO Collaborating Center for Research and Training in Mental Health, Okasha Institute of Psychiatry, Ain Shams University, Egypt, email
Int Psychiatry. 2011 Nov 1;8(4):79-81. eCollection 2011 Nov.
Are we in need of including in our diagnostic systems a new category of subthreshold psychiatry? Studies have shown that we are faced in our daily clinical practice with many patients who do not fulfil the criteria of either ICD-10 or DSM-IV (at best they may be included under 'atypical', 'unspecified' or 'not elsewhere classified'). Subthreshold cases or prodromal psychotic or non-psychotic clinical cases are encountered frequently in clinical practice, especially primary care (Knappe , 2008), but because of some ethical and nosological issues their needs are unmet. Pharmacological interventions for such conditions are denied in some countries, especially with managed care, where maximisation of profit and minimisation of cost are often the main objectives. It has been reported that the early treatment of many disorders ensures a better outcome and better assimilation in society and reduces residual manifestations of disease. Recent data suggest that the impairment and disability caused by subsyndromal disorders are almost equal to those caused by syndromal ones. We need more scientific data and research studies to evaluate the course, outcome and value of treating such disorders.
我们是否需要在诊断系统中纳入一个新的阈下精神病学类别?研究表明,在日常临床实践中,我们面对许多不符合ICD - 10或DSM - IV标准的患者(充其量他们可能被归入“非典型”“未特定”或“未在他处分类”)。阈下病例或前驱性精神病性或非精神病性临床病例在临床实践中经常遇到,尤其是在初级保健中(克纳普,2008年),但由于一些伦理和疾病分类学问题,他们的需求未得到满足。在一些国家,尤其是在管理式医疗中,此类病症的药物干预被拒绝,在管理式医疗中,利润最大化和成本最小化往往是主要目标。据报道,许多疾病的早期治疗可确保更好的预后以及更好地融入社会,并减少疾病的残留表现。最近的数据表明,亚综合征性疾病所导致的损害和残疾几乎与综合征性疾病所导致的相同。我们需要更多的科学数据和研究来评估治疗此类疾病的病程、预后和价值。