Department of Occupational Therapy, Prosthetics and Orthotics, Faculty of Health Sciences, Oslo Metropolitan University, Oslo, Norway.
Faculty of Technology, Art and Design, Oslo Metropolitan University, Oslo, Norway.
Disabil Rehabil. 2021 May;43(9):1323-1332. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2019.1662495. Epub 2019 Sep 17.
To investigate the internal consistency, convergent and known-groups construct validity of the Figure-of-Eight Walk Test with two novel conditions in persons with lower limb amputation, and to examine differences in walking performance between the three conditions within a group of persons with transtibial amputation and transfemoral amputation/knee disarticulation.
Fifty adults with unilateral amputation participated, 28 of whom had undergone a transtibial amputation and 22 a transfemoral amputation/knee disarticulation. Three Figure-of-Eight Walk Test conditions were investigated: 1) walking at a self-selected walking speed, 2) walking while carrying a tray with two cups of water, and 3) walking on uneven terrain. Internal consistency was evaluated using Cronbach's alpha. Convergent construct validity was examined by analysing the relationship between the Figure-of-Eight Walk Test parameters and performance-based parameters (Amputee Mobility Predictor, Ten-Meter Walk Test, Six-Minute Walk Test) and self-report measures (Prosthetic Limb Users Survey of Mobility, Activities-specific Balance Confidence Scale) using Spearman's rank-order correlations. Known-groups construct validity was assessed by comparing the Figure-of-Eight Walk Test parameters based on anatomical level of amputation. Friedman's test and analysis were used to examine differences between the walking conditions within each group.
Cronbach's alpha coefficients of the Figure-of-Eight Walk Test parameters for all three conditions ranged from 0.89 to 0.99. The Figure-of-Eight Walk Test time and step parameters demonstrated moderate to good correlation ( = -0.50 to -0.77) for performance-based mobility measures. The correlations were stronger during Condition 3 in comparison with the original Figure-of-Eight Walk Test. The correlation was fair to good ( = -0.41 to -0.57) for the self-report mobility measures. Comparison between groups showed a difference between transtibial and transfemoral amputation/knee disarticulation participants when it comes to the Figure-of-Eight Walk Test time and smoothness parameters in Condition 2 ( < 0.05). Comparison between walking conditions within each group showed significant differences in the Figure-of-Eight Walk Test parameters in the two novel conditions in comparison with the original Figure-of-Eight Walk Test. The Figure-of-Eight Walk Test and the novel conditions demonstrated excellent internal consistency, good convergent construct validity, and evidence of known-groups construct validity. Future studies should further develop and standardise the smoothness scale to better quantify walking performance and assess the responsiveness and reliability (inter-rater and intra-rater) of the Figure-of-Eight Walk Test (time and steps) and the novel conditions, while studies on known-groups validity should include persons with a wider mobility range.IMPLICATIONS FOR REHABILITATIONFigure-of-Eight Walk Test with the two novel conditions, which include carrying a load and walking on uneven terrain, may help to provide meaningful information about walking ability in daily life.The two novel conditions pose different challenges to persons with lower limb amputation when compared to the original Figure-of-Eight Walk Test and underscore the relevance to assess mobility under challenging walking conditions.The Figure-of-Eight Walk Test and the two novel conditions demonstrated excellent internal consistency, good convergent construct validity, and evidence of known-groups construct validity.
研究两种新型条件下下肢截肢患者的 8 字形走试验的内部一致性、收敛和已知组构效性,并检验 28 例接受胫骨截肢和 22 例股骨截肢/膝关节离断患者在这三种条件下的步行表现差异。
50 名单侧截肢成年人参与了研究,其中 28 名接受了胫骨截肢,22 名接受了股骨截肢/膝关节离断。研究了 8 字形走试验的三种条件:1)以自选择的步行速度行走,2)携带两杯水的托盘行走,3)在不平坦的地形上行走。采用 Cronbach's alpha 评估内部一致性。通过分析 8 字形走试验参数与基于表现的参数(截肢者移动预测器、10 米步行测试、6 分钟步行测试)和自我报告措施(假肢使用者移动调查、活动特定平衡信心量表)之间的关系,检验收敛构效性,使用 Spearman 等级相关。采用 Friedman 检验和检验分析评估基于截肢解剖水平的 8 字形走试验参数的组间差异。
所有三种条件下 8 字形走试验参数的 Cronbach's alpha 系数范围为 0.89 至 0.99。8 字形走试验时间和步幅参数与基于表现的移动性测量之间存在中度至高度相关性( = -0.50 至 -0.77)。与原始 8 字形走试验相比,条件 3 下的相关性更强。与自我报告的移动性测量相关( = -0.41 至 -0.57),具有良好的相关性。组间比较显示,在条件 2 中,胫骨截肢和股骨截肢/膝关节离断患者的 8 字形走试验时间和平滑度参数存在差异( < 0.05)。在每个组内的行走条件之间的比较显示,在原始 8 字形走试验的两种新型条件下,8 字形走试验参数存在显著差异。8 字形走试验和新型条件表现出良好的内部一致性、良好的收敛构效性和已知组构效性的证据。未来的研究应进一步开发和标准化平滑度量表,以更好地量化行走表现,并评估 8 字形走试验(时间和步数)和新型条件的反应性和可靠性(评定者间和评定者内),同时,对已知组构效性的研究应包括具有更广泛活动范围的人群。
接受胫骨截肢和股骨截肢/膝关节离断的患者的 8 字形走试验,以及包括携带负荷和在不平坦地形上行走的两种新型条件,可能有助于提供有关日常生活中行走能力的有意义的信息。与原始 8 字形走试验相比,两种新型条件给下肢截肢患者带来了不同的挑战,强调了在挑战性行走条件下评估移动能力的重要性。8 字形走试验和两种新型条件均表现出良好的内部一致性、良好的收敛构效性和已知组构效性的证据。