Department of Plant Pathology, China Agricultural University, Beijing, China.
Department of Plant Pathology, Northwest Agricultural & Forest University, Yangling, China.
Phytopathology. 2019 Dec;109(12):2096-2106. doi: 10.1094/PHYTO-01-19-0032-R. Epub 2019 Nov 4.
Ethaboxam is a β-tubulin inhibitor registered for the control of oomycete pathogens. The current study was established to determine the ethaboxam sensitivity of the plant pathogen and investigate the potential for the emergence of fungicide resistance. The effective concentration for 50% inhibition (EC) of 112 isolates exhibited a unimodal distribution with a mean EC for ethaboxam of 0.033 µg/ml. Establishing this baseline sensitivity provided critical data for monitoring changes in ethaboxam-sensitivity in field populations. The potential for fungicide resistance was investigated using adaptation on ethaboxam-amended V8 agar, which resulted in the isolation of 20 resistant mutants. An assessment of the biological characteristics of the mutants including mycelial growth, sporulation, germination rate and pathogenicity indicated that the resistance risk in was low to medium with no cross-resistance between ethaboxam and cymoxanil, metalaxyl, flumorph, and oxathiapiprolin being detected. However, positive cross-resistance was found between ethaboxam and zoxamide for Q8L and I258V but negative cross-resistance for C165Y. Further investigation revealed that the ethaboxam-resistant mutants had point mutations at amino acids Q8L, C165Y, or I258V of their β-tubulin protein sequences. CRISPR/Cas9-mediated transformation experiments confirmed that the Q8L, C165Y, or I258V mutations could confer ethaboxam resistance in and that the C165Y mutation induces high levels of resistance. Taken together, the results of the study provide essential data for monitoring the emergence of resistance and resistance management strategies for ethaboxam, as well as for improving the design of novel β-tubulin inhibitors for future development.
乙氧呋草黄是一种已注册用于防治卵菌病原体的β-微管蛋白抑制剂。本研究旨在确定植物病原菌对乙氧呋草黄的敏感性,并研究产生抗药性的潜力。112 个分离株的 50%抑制有效浓度(EC)呈单峰分布,乙氧呋草黄的平均 EC 值为 0.033μg/ml。建立这一基础敏感性为监测田间种群中乙氧呋草黄敏感性的变化提供了关键数据。使用乙氧呋草黄添加 V8 琼脂进行适应性试验,从而分离出 20 个抗性突变体,研究了抗药性的潜力。对突变体的生物学特性进行评估,包括菌丝生长、孢子形成、萌发率和致病性,结果表明,对的抗性风险为低到中等,乙氧呋草黄与 Cymoxanil、Metalaxyl、Flumorph 和 Oxathiapiprolin 之间未检测到交叉抗性,但在 Q8L 和 I258V 之间检测到乙氧呋草黄与 Zoxamide 的正交叉抗性,而在 C165Y 之间检测到负交叉抗性。进一步研究表明,乙氧呋草黄抗性突变体在其β-微管蛋白序列的氨基酸 Q8L、C165Y 或 I258V 处发生点突变。CRISPR/Cas9 介导的转化实验证实,Q8L、C165Y 或 I258V 突变可赋予对乙氧呋草黄的抗性,且 C165Y 突变诱导高水平抗性。综上所述,该研究结果为监测乙氧呋草黄抗性的出现以及抗性管理策略提供了必要数据,同时也为设计新型β-微管蛋白抑制剂以用于未来开发提供了参考。