Centre for Health Research and Development, Society for Applied Studies, New Delhi, India.
Department of Maternal, Newborn, Child and Adolescent Health, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Lancet. 2019 Nov 9;394(10210):1724-1736. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(19)32223-8. Epub 2019 Oct 4.
Coverage of kangaroo mother care remains very low despite WHO recommendations for its use for babies with low birthweight in health facilities for over a decade. Initiating kangaroo mother care at the community level is a promising strategy to increase coverage. However, knowledge of the efficacy of community-initiated kangaroo mother care is still lacking. We aimed to assess the effect of community-initiated kangaroo mother care provided to babies weighing 1500-2250 g on neonatal and infant survival.
In this randomised controlled, superiority trial, undertaken in Haryana, India, we enrolled babies weighing 1500-2250 g at home within 72 h of birth, if not already initiated in kangaroo mother care, irrespective of place of birth (ie, home or health facility) and who were stable and feeding. The first eligible infants in households were randomly assigned (1:1) to the intervention (community-initiated kangaroo mother care) or control group by block randomisation using permuted blocks of variable size. Twins were allocated to the same group. For second eligible infants in the same household as an enrolled infant, if the first infant was assigned to the intervention group the second infant was also assigned to this group, whereas if the first infant was assigned to the control group the second infant was randomly assigned (1:1) to the intervention or control group. Mothers and infants in the intervention group were visited at home (days 1-3, 5, 7, 10, 14, 21, and 28) to support kangaroo mother care (ie, skin-to-skin contact and exclusive breastfeeding). The control group received routine care. The two primary outcomes were mortality between enrolment and 28 days and between enrolment and 180 days. Analysis was by intention to treat and adjusted for clustering within households. The effect of the intervention on mortality was assessed with person-time in the denominator using Cox proportional hazards model. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT02653534 and NCT02631343, and is now closed to new participants.
Between July 30, 2015, and Oct 31, 2018, 8402 babies were enrolled, of whom 4480 were assigned to the intervention group and 3922 to the control group. Most births (6837 [81·4%]) occurred at a health facility, 36·2% (n=3045) had initiated breastfeeding within 1 h of birth, and infants were enrolled at an average of about 30 h (SD 17) of age. Vital status was known for 4470 infants in the intervention group and 3914 in the control group at age 28 days, and for 3653 in the intervention group and 3331 in the control group at age 180 days. Between enrolment and 28 days, 73 infants died in 4423 periods of 28 days in the intervention group and 90 deaths in 3859 periods of 28 days in the control group (hazard ratio [HR] 0·70, 95% CI 0·51-0·96; p=0·027). Between enrolment and 180 days, 158 infants died in 3965 periods of 180 days in the intervention group and 184 infants died in 3514 periods of 180 days in the control group (HR 0·75, 0·60-0·93; p=0·010). The risk ratios for death were almost the same as the HRs (28-day mortality 0·71, 95% CI 0·52- 0·97; p=0·032; 180-day mortality 0·76, 0·60-0·95; p=0·017).
Community-initiated kangaroo mother care substantially improves newborn baby and infant survival. In low-income and middle-income countries, incorporation of kangaroo mother care for all infants with low birthweight, irrespective of place of birth, could substantially reduce neonatal and infant mortality.
Research Council of Norway and University of Bergen.
尽管世界卫生组织建议在卫生机构中为低出生体重儿提供袋鼠式护理已有十多年,但袋鼠式护理的覆盖率仍然很低。在社区一级启动袋鼠式护理是增加覆盖率的一个很有前景的策略。然而,对于社区启动的袋鼠式护理的效果仍缺乏了解。我们旨在评估对体重在 1500-2250 克之间的婴儿在社区一级实施袋鼠式护理对新生儿和婴儿存活率的影响。
在印度哈里亚纳邦进行的这项随机对照、优效性试验中,我们招募了出生后 72 小时内体重在 1500-2250 克之间、在家中且尚未开始接受袋鼠式护理的婴儿,无论出生地点(即家庭或卫生机构)和喂养情况如何。第一个符合条件的在家中的婴儿通过按大小可变的区组随机化(区组大小为 1-16)被随机分配到干预组(社区启动的袋鼠式护理)或对照组。双胞胎被分配到同一组。对于同一家庭中已登记婴儿的第二个符合条件的婴儿,如果第一个婴儿被分配到干预组,那么第二个婴儿也被分配到该组,而如果第一个婴儿被分配到对照组,那么第二个婴儿将被随机分配(1-1)到干预组或对照组。在家庭中访问干预组的母亲和婴儿(第 1-3、5、7、10、14、21 和 28 天)以支持袋鼠式护理(即皮肤对皮肤接触和纯母乳喂养)。对照组接受常规护理。两个主要结局是登记至 28 天和登记至 180 天的死亡率。通过 Cox 比例风险模型,在分母中使用人时进行分析,并调整了家庭内的聚类。通过生存分析评估干预对死亡率的影响。这项研究在 ClinicalTrials.gov 上注册,NCT02653534 和 NCT02631343,现在已经对新参与者关闭。
2015 年 7 月 30 日至 2018 年 10 月 31 日,共纳入 8402 名婴儿,其中 4480 名被分配到干预组,3922 名被分配到对照组。大多数分娩(6837[81.4%])发生在卫生机构,36.2%(n=3045)在出生后 1 小时内开始母乳喂养,婴儿平均在出生后约 30 小时(标准差 17)被登记。干预组有 4470 名婴儿和对照组有 3914 名婴儿在 28 天龄时的生命状态已知,有 3653 名婴儿在干预组和 3331 名婴儿在对照组在 180 天龄时的生命状态已知。在登记至 28 天期间,干预组 28 天期间的 4423 个周期中有 73 名婴儿死亡,对照组有 3859 个周期中有 90 名婴儿死亡(风险比[HR]0.70,95%CI0.51-0.96;p=0.027)。在登记至 180 天期间,干预组 180 天期间的 3965 个周期中有 158 名婴儿死亡,对照组有 3514 个周期中有 184 名婴儿死亡(HR0.75,0.60-0.93;p=0.010)。死亡的风险比几乎与 HR 相同(28 天死亡率 0.71,95%CI0.52-0.97;p=0.032;180 天死亡率 0.76,0.60-0.95;p=0.017)。
社区启动的袋鼠式护理显著提高了新生儿和婴儿的存活率。在低收入和中等收入国家,为所有低出生体重儿提供袋鼠式护理,无论出生地点如何,都可能大大降低新生儿和婴儿的死亡率。
挪威研究理事会和卑尔根大学。