College of Chemistry and Environmental Engineering, Shenzhen University, 518060, Shenzhen, China.
Shenzhen Hydrology and Water Quality Center, 518055, Shenzhen, China.
Chemosphere. 2020 Apr;245:125634. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.125634. Epub 2019 Dec 14.
Road deposited sediments (RDS) is the key carrier of pollutants in the urban road stormwater processes and hence has been seen as an important pollutant source of urban road stormwater. Although many research studies have focused on RDS and pollutants attached to RDS, the investigation on RDS toxicity is very limited. Toxicity test can permit an overall assessment on whether the RDS polluted stormwater can be safely reused. This paper used two living organisms, namely Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, (mammalian cells to indicate human health related toxicity) and Chlorella Pyrenoidosa (algae to indicate ecological health related toxicity) to test RDS toxicity by using an innovative "equivalent toxicity area (ETA)" approach. The outcomes showed that mammalian cells are more sensitive than algae in terms of RDS toxicity. Pb, Cd and Cr primarily contributed to mammalian cell-based toxicity while Zn, Ni, Cu and TOC are primarily toxic to algae. It is also found that road site characteristics such as land uses exerted an important influence on RDS toxicity. Commercial areas tended to generate RDS with higher human health risk related toxicity while industrial areas had a potential to produce RDS with high ecological health risk related toxicity. The research outcomes also showed that solely focusing on pollutant themselves on RDS can not accurately indicate RDS pollution. An approach to considering both pollutant loads and toxicity is preferred. These results were expected to provide a useful insight to enhancing effectiveness of RDS polluted urban road stormwater management and ensuring their reuse safety.
道路沉积物(RDS)是城市道路雨水过程中污染物的关键载体,因此被视为城市道路雨水的重要污染源。尽管许多研究都集中在 RDS 和附着在 RDS 上的污染物上,但对 RDS 毒性的调查非常有限。毒性测试可以对受污染的雨水是否可以安全再利用进行全面评估。本文使用两种生物,即中国仓鼠卵巢(CHO)细胞(哺乳动物细胞,用于指示与人类健康相关的毒性)和栅藻(藻类,用于指示与生态健康相关的毒性),通过创新的“等效毒性面积(ETA)”方法来测试 RDS 毒性。结果表明,在 RDS 毒性方面,哺乳动物细胞比藻类更敏感。Pb、Cd 和 Cr 主要导致哺乳动物细胞毒性,而 Zn、Ni、Cu 和 TOC 主要对藻类有毒。研究还发现,道路场地特征(如土地利用)对 RDS 毒性有重要影响。商业区产生的 RDS 具有更高的与人类健康相关的毒性风险,而工业区则有可能产生具有高生态健康风险相关毒性的 RDS。研究结果还表明,仅关注 RDS 上的污染物本身不能准确指示 RDS 污染。优先考虑考虑污染物负荷和毒性的方法。这些结果有望为提高受污染的城市道路雨水管理的有效性和确保其再利用安全提供有用的见解。