Otomo Aki, Singh Ameet, Jeong Junemoe, Dobberstein Rachel, Lundhild Alexandra, Peter Elyse, Brisson Brigitte, Oblak Michelle, Milovancev Milan
Department of Clinical Studies, Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Veterinary Clinical Sciences, Louisiana State University, School of Veterinary Medicine, Baton Rouge, Louisiana.
Vet Surg. 2020 Apr;49(3):436-444. doi: 10.1111/vsu.13384. Epub 2020 Jan 22.
To compare long-term clinical outcomes of dogs with single congenital extrahepatic portosystemic shunts (CEHPSS) treated with thin film banding (TFB) consisting of polyolefin fiber or ameroid ring constrictor (ARC) placement in dogs.
Retrospective, two-center clinical study.
Client-owned dogs (n = 123) with single CEHPSS undergoing gradual attenuation via TFB (n = 85) or ARC (n = 38).
Medical records of dogs with CEHPSS were reviewed. Follow-up data were collected from the referring veterinarian and/or owner via standardized questionnaire. Data were analyzed to compare short-term mortality rate and long-term outcome (>6 months).
Dogs in the TFB group were older than dogs in the ARC group (median age, 19 vs 12 months, respectively; P = .01). There was no difference in survival to discharge between dogs in the TFB (81/85 [95.3%]) and ARC (37/38 [97.4%]; P > .99) groups. Preoperative levetiracetam was more frequently administered to dogs treated with TFB (64/85 [75.3%]) than to dogs treated with ARC (15/38 [39.5%;] P = .0002). Postoperative seizures were reported in 10 (8.1%) dogs; their prevalence did not differ between dogs treated with TFB (9/85 [10.6%]) and dogs treated with ARC (1/38 [2.6%]; P = .17). Median follow-up time for dogs treated with TFB (58.0 months, range 8-130) and ARC (63.3 months, range 7-138; P = .24) did not differ.
Gradual attenuation of a single CEHPSS with either TFB or ARC resulted in similar long-term clinical outcomes and low postoperative morbidity and mortality rates.
Thin film banding (polyolefin fiber) offers an alternative leading to clinical outcomes similar to ARC in dogs with single CEHPSS.
比较采用聚烯烃纤维薄膜绑扎(TFB)或阿米洛环缩窄器(ARC)治疗的患有单一先天性肝外门体分流(CEHPSS)的犬的长期临床结局。
回顾性、双中心临床研究。
123只患有单一CEHPSS的客户拥有的犬,通过TFB(n = 85)或ARC(n = 38)进行逐渐减流。
回顾患有CEHPSS的犬的病历。通过标准化问卷从转诊兽医和/或主人处收集随访数据。分析数据以比较短期死亡率和长期结局(>6个月)。
TFB组的犬比ARC组的犬年龄大(中位年龄分别为19个月和12个月;P = 0.01)。TFB组(81/85 [95.3%])和ARC组(37/38 [97.4%];P > 0.99)的犬出院存活率无差异。术前左乙拉西坦在接受TFB治疗的犬(64/85 [75.3%])中比接受ARC治疗的犬(15/38 [39.5%];P = 0.0002)中更频繁使用。10只(8.1%)犬报告有术后癫痫发作;接受TFB治疗的犬(9/85 [10.6%])和接受ARC治疗的犬(1/38 [2.6%];P = 0.17)之间其发生率无差异。接受TFB治疗的犬(58.0个月,范围8 - 130个月)和接受ARC治疗的犬(63.3个月,范围7 - 138个月;P = 0.24)的中位随访时间无差异。
采用TFB或ARC对单一CEHPSS进行逐渐减流可导致相似的长期临床结局以及较低的术后发病率和死亡率。
薄膜绑扎(聚烯烃纤维)为患有单一CEHPSS的犬提供了一种可导致与ARC相似临床结局的替代方法。