Epidemiology Unit, Health Research Institute-Fundación Jiménez Díaz University Hospital, Universidad Autónoma De Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
Expert Rev Clin Pharmacol. 2020 Mar;13(3):205-210. doi: 10.1080/17512433.2020.1732816. Epub 2020 Mar 9.
: An important gap within modern medicine is the lack of enough comparative effectiveness research of marketed medicines. Low-risk pragmatic randomized controlled trials (pRCTs) are those conducted resembling usual clinical practice that poses no or minimal incremental risk compared with normal clinical practice.: This review addresses one important hurdle in the conduct of low-risk pRCTs: the need to seek participants' written informed consent.: The CIOMS ethical guidelines consider that any research that (a) would not be feasible or practicable to carry out without the waiver or modification, (b) has important social value, and (c) poses no more than minimal risks to participants, and that is approved by the relevant research ethics committee, could be conducted without participants' consent. It is clear that these provisions are applicable to some low-risk RCTs. Recently a research on the EU-CTR registry showed that only 2% of all ongoing phase 4 RCTs could have fulfilled the CIOMS provisions following the investigators' assessment. The EU clinical trial regulation - and that of other jurisdictions - should be debated on the suitableness of the conduct with an alteration or waiver of participants' consent of those low-risk pRCTs that fulfill the three CIOMS provisions.
现代医学的一个重要空白是缺乏对已上市药物的足够的比较疗效研究。低风险实用随机对照试验(pRCT)是指在与常规临床实践相比不存在或仅存在最小增量风险的情况下进行的类似常规临床实践的试验。
本综述探讨了进行低风险 pRCT 时的一个重要障碍:需要寻求参与者的书面知情同意。
CIOMS 伦理准则认为,任何研究如果(a)没有放弃或修改就不可行或不可行,(b)具有重要的社会价值,并且(c)对参与者造成的风险不超过最小限度,并且已获得相关研究伦理委员会的批准,则可以在没有参与者同意的情况下进行。显然,这些规定适用于一些低风险 RCT。最近一项关于欧盟-CTR 登记处的研究表明,根据研究人员的评估,在所有正在进行的 4 期 RCT 中,只有 2% 可能符合 CIOMS 的规定。欧盟临床试验法规——以及其他司法管辖区的法规——应就那些符合 CIOMS 三项规定的低风险 pRCT 进行修改或放弃参与者同意的可行性进行辩论。