Mahr Katharina, Bergmann Marc-Philipp, Kay Lara, Möller Leona, Reif Philipp S, Willems Laurent M, Menzler Katja, Schubert-Bast Susanne, Klein Karl Martin, Knake Susanne, Rosenow Felix, Zöllner Johann Philipp, Strzelczyk Adam
Epilepsy Center Frankfurt Rhine-Main, Department of Neurology, Goethe-University Frankfurt, Frankfurt am Main, Germany; LOEWE Center for Personalized and Translational Epilepsy Research (CePTER), Goethe-University Frankfurt, Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
Epilepsy Center Hessen and Department of Neurology, Philipps-University Marburg, Marburg (Lahn), Germany.
Seizure. 2020 Feb 21;76:173-178. doi: 10.1016/j.seizure.2020.02.008.
Most patients who die from sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) are found in the prone position. We evaluated whether changes in body position occur during generalized convulsive seizures (GCSs).
GCSs in patients undergoing video-EEG-monitoring between 2007 and 2017 at epilepsy centers in Frankfurt and Marburg were analyzed in relation to changes in body position.
A total of 494 GCSs were analyzed among 327 patients. At seizure onset, positions included supine (48.2 %), right lateral (19.0 %), left lateral (15.6 %), sitting or standing (14.0 %), and prone (3.2 %). Between seizure onset and the start of generalization, 57.5 % of participants altered body positions. During four seizures, patients adopted a prone position, while, in five seizures, patients moved from a prone position. Patients who experienced GCS onset while in a nonprone position had a 2.1 % risk of entering the prone position by the end of their seizure. In contrast, 56.2 % of those in an initial prone position remained so at the end of the GCS, with an odds ratio for maintaining that position of 60.2 (95 % confidence interval: 29.1-124.3; p < 0.001). The likelihood of ending up in the prone position post-GCS did not vary among patients with different nonprone starting positions (p = 0.147).
Seizures in prone position occur during sleep and the highest risk for postictal prone positioning appears to be being in the prone position at GCS onset. Epilepsy patients should therefore be advised to go to sleep in a supine or lateral position to reduce their SUDEP risk.
大多数死于癫痫性猝死(SUDEP)的患者被发现处于俯卧位。我们评估了全身惊厥性癫痫发作(GCSs)期间体位是否会发生变化。
对2007年至2017年在法兰克福和马尔堡癫痫中心接受视频脑电图监测的患者的GCSs与体位变化进行了分析。
共分析了327例患者的494次GCSs。癫痫发作开始时,体位包括仰卧位(48.2%)、右侧卧位(19.0%)、左侧卧位(15.6%)、坐或站(14.0%)以及俯卧位(3.2%)。在癫痫发作开始至泛化开始之间,57.5%的参与者改变了体位。在4次发作期间,患者采取了俯卧位,而在5次发作中患者从俯卧位移动。在非俯卧位开始癫痫发作的患者在发作结束时进入俯卧位的风险为2.1%。相比之下,初始处于俯卧位的患者中有56.2%在GCS结束时仍保持该体位,保持该体位的优势比为60.2(95%置信区间:29.1 - 124.3;p < 0.001)。GCS后最终处于俯卧位的可能性在不同非俯卧起始体位的患者中没有差异(p = 0.147)。
俯卧位发作发生在睡眠期间,发作后俯卧位的最高风险似乎是在GCS发作开始时处于俯卧位。因此,应建议癫痫患者仰卧或侧卧入睡以降低其SUDEP风险。