The aim of this study was to survey an international group of temporomandibular joint surgeons regarding their outcomes with alloplastic total joint replacement in skeletally immature patients and to review the literature linked to autogenous reconstruction and alloplastic replacement of the temporomandibular joint (TMJR) in this population. A total of 24 custom/patient-specific TMJ Concepts devices were implanted into 14 patients (eight male and six female). Their mean age was 14 years (range 7-17 years). Nine (64.3%) had bilateral devices and five (35.7%) had unilateral devices. The most prevalent diagnosis was idiopathic condylar resorption (33.3%), followed by ankylosis (16.7%). Concurrent orthognathic surgery was performed in four patients (28.6%). The TMJR was completed as a one-stage procedure in 11 patients (78.6%) and in two stages in three patients (21.4%). All surgeons reported improvements in maximum incisal opening with good function. The respondents reported no asymmetric mandibular growth or retrognathia after either bilateral or unilateral TMJR implantation. This pilot study indicates that the use of TMJR in the growing patient may be a useful modality in select cases. The encouraging results of experienced surgeons demonstrate and support the need for further studies on the utilization of TMJR in this patient population.