Poling Mikaela I, Dufresne Craig R, Chamberlain Robert L
Fairfax, VA.
Georgetown University, Washington, DC.
J Craniofac Surg. 2020 Jun;31(4):1063-1069. doi: 10.1097/SCS.0000000000006299.
Freeman-Burian syndrome (FBS) is a rare congenital myopathic craniofacial syndrome. Since publication of the genotype-correlated clinical diagnostic criteria, no complete survey of the literature has been accomplished. As part of the clinical practice guideline development, we evaluate diagnostic accuracy for FBS from 1938 to 2019 and range of findings, complications, treatments, and outcomes. Published manuscripts in PubMed, Google Scholar, and OMIM describing cases with a reported diagnosis of FBS, Sheldon-Hall syndrome, and distal arthrogryposes type 1 and 3 are initially included. Articles with sufficient case-level data for diagnosis verification are analyzed further. Of 724 unique papers considered, 188 papers describing 304 unique patients are included; 101 papers and 119 patients reflect an FBS diagnosis, with 80 patients meeting the full diagnostic criteria. Most cases are re-screened as distal arthrogryposis type 1. Among all cases re-screened as FBS, the presence of FBS pathognomonic craniofacial findings is not correlated with other physical findings. There are no significant differences between patients meeting the full diagnostic criteria and those not, but both are distinct from other diagnoses. Plastic surgery demonstrates the highest cumulative diagnostic accuracy for FBS overall (86.66%), while orthopedic surgery shows the lowest (44.83%). No statistically usable treatment-related or psychosocial data are available. Quality of case reports and patient data vary widely, reducing the statistical strength and significance. Major knowledge gaps exist in treatment, psychosocial, and longitudinal outcomes. At this point, it is impossible to derive clinical practice guidelines exclusively from the literature.
弗里曼-布里安综合征(FBS)是一种罕见的先天性肌病性颅面综合征。自与基因型相关的临床诊断标准发布以来,尚未完成对文献的全面综述。作为临床实践指南制定的一部分,我们评估了1938年至2019年FBS的诊断准确性以及相关发现、并发症、治疗方法和结果的范围。最初纳入了在PubMed、谷歌学术和OMIM上发表的描述诊断为FBS、谢尔顿-霍尔综合征以及1型和3型远端关节挛缩症病例的手稿。对具有足够病例水平数据以进行诊断验证的文章进行进一步分析。在考虑的724篇独特论文中,纳入了描述304例独特患者的188篇论文;101篇论文和119例患者反映了FBS诊断,其中80例患者符合完整诊断标准。大多数病例被重新筛查为1型远端关节挛缩症。在所有重新筛查为FBS的病例中,FBS典型的颅面表现与其他身体表现无关。符合完整诊断标准的患者与不符合的患者之间没有显著差异,但两者均与其他诊断不同。总体而言,整形外科对FBS的累积诊断准确性最高(86.66%),而矫形外科最低(44.83%)。没有可用的具有统计学意义的治疗相关或社会心理数据。病例报告和患者数据的质量差异很大,降低了统计强度和显著性。在治疗、社会心理和纵向结果方面存在重大知识空白。此时,不可能仅从文献中得出临床实践指南。