Am Nat. 2020 May;195(5):833-850. doi: 10.1086/708270. Epub 2020 Apr 8.
Global change may induce changes in savanna and forest distributions, but the dynamics of these changes remain unclear. Classical biome theory suggests that climate is predictive of biome distributions, such that shifts will be continuous and reversible. This view, however, cannot explain the overlap in the climatic ranges of tropical biomes, which some argue may result from fire-vegetation feedbacks, maintaining savanna and forest as bistable states. Under this view, biome shifts are argued to be discontinuous and irreversible. Mean-field bistable models, however, are also limited, as they cannot reproduce the spatial aggregation of biomes. Here we suggest that both models ignore spatial processes, such as dispersal, which may be important when savanna and forest abut. We examine the contributions of dispersal to determining biome distributions using a 2D reaction-diffusion model, comparing results qualitatively to empirical savanna and forest distributions in sub-Saharan Africa. We find that the diffusion model resolves both the aforementioned limitations of biome models. First, local dispersive spatial interactions, with an underlying precipitation gradient, can reproduce the spatial aggregation of biomes with a stable savanna-forest boundary. Second, the boundary is determined not only by the amount of precipitation but also by the geometrical shape of the precipitation contours. These geometrical effects arise from continental-scale source-sink dynamics, which reproduce the mismatch between biome and climate. Dynamically, the spatial model predicts that dispersal may increase the resilience of tropical biome in response to global change: the boundary continuously tracks climate, recovering following disturbances, unless the remnant biome patches are too small.
全球变化可能会引起热带稀树草原和森林分布的变化,但这些变化的动态仍不清楚。经典生物群落理论表明,气候是生物群落分布的预测因子,因此变化将是连续和可逆的。然而,这种观点无法解释热带生物群落气候范围的重叠,一些人认为这可能是由于火-植被反馈,使稀树草原和森林保持在双稳态。根据这种观点,生物群落的转变被认为是不连续和不可逆的。然而,均值场双稳态模型也存在局限性,因为它们无法再现生物群落的空间聚集。在这里,我们认为这两种模型都忽略了空间过程,如扩散,当稀树草原和森林相邻时,扩散可能很重要。我们使用二维反应扩散模型来检验扩散对确定生物群落分布的贡献,并将结果与撒哈拉以南非洲的经验性稀树草原和森林分布进行定性比较。我们发现扩散模型解决了生物群落模型的上述两个局限性。首先,局部扩散空间相互作用,以潜在的降水梯度为基础,可以再现具有稳定稀树草原-森林边界的生物群落的空间聚集。其次,边界不仅由降水量决定,还由降水轮廓的几何形状决定。这些几何效应源于大陆尺度的源-汇动力学,再现了生物群落和气候之间的不匹配。从动态上看,空间模型预测,扩散可能会增加热带生物群落对全球变化的恢复力:边界连续跟踪气候,在受到干扰后恢复,除非剩余的生物群落斑块太小。