Carretero G, Carrascosa J M, Puig L, Sánchez-Carazo J L, López-Ferrer A, Cueva P, Soria C, Rivera R, Belinchón I
Hospital Universitario de Gran Canaria Doctor Negrín, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain.
Hospital Universitario Germans Trias i Pujol, Badalona, Barcelona, Spain.
J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2021 Feb;35(2):422-430. doi: 10.1111/jdv.16564. Epub 2020 Jul 28.
To generate an operational definition to adequately reflect the construct 'Minimal Disease Activity (MDA)' in psoriasis.
A systematic review of domains included in clinical trials of psoriasis was presented to a panel of dermatologists and patients. Further domains were elicited by panel discussions. Domains (and instruments measuring these) were items of two consecutive Delphi rounds targeting dermatologists from the Psoriasis Group of the Spanish Academy of Dermatology and Venereology and patients from the Acción Psoriasis association. The instruments selected were used to generate 388 patient vignettes. The expert group then classified these vignettes as 'No MDA/MDA/Unclassifiable'. The items were further reduced by factorial analysis. Using the classification variable as gold standard, several operational constructions were tested in regression models and ROC curves and accuracy was evaluated with area under the curve (AUC).
The following domains were included: itching, scaling, erythema and visibility by 0-10 scales, extension by BSA, impact on quality of life by DLQI, special location and presence of arthritis as yes/no. The definition with the highest AUC and best balance between sensitivity and specificity was the one including no presence of arthritis plus at least three others below the upper limit of the 95% confidence interval (AUC, 0.897; sensitivity, 95.2%, specificity, 84.1%).
This study provides, for the very first time, the construct of 'Minimal Disease Activity' in psoriasis as agreed by dermatologists and patients. MDA is defined as absence of active arthritis plus 3 out of 6: itching ≤ 1/10; scaling ≤ 2/10; redness ≤ 2/10; visibility ≤ 2/10; BSA ≤ 2; DLQI ≤ 2; and no lesions in special locations. By design, domains are representative of disease impact. This MDA definition may be used as a measure of adequate management and replace other subjective or restrictive tools.
制定一个可操作的定义,以充分反映银屑病中的“最小疾病活动度(MDA)”这一概念。
向一组皮肤科医生和患者展示了对银屑病临床试验中所包含领域的系统评价。通过小组讨论引出了更多领域。领域(以及测量这些领域的工具)是针对西班牙皮肤病学与性病学学会银屑病组的皮肤科医生和银屑病行动协会的患者进行的连续两轮德尔菲法的项目。所选择的工具用于生成388个患者病例。然后专家组将这些病例分类为“无MDA/有MDA/无法分类”。通过因子分析进一步减少项目。以分类变量作为金标准,在回归模型和ROC曲线中测试了几种可操作的构建,并通过曲线下面积(AUC)评估准确性。
纳入了以下领域:瘙痒、鳞屑、红斑以及用0 - 10分制表示的可见度、体表面积(BSA)扩展、皮肤病生活质量指数(DLQI)对生活质量的影响、特殊部位以及关节炎的存在情况(是/否)。AUC最高且敏感性和特异性之间平衡最佳的定义是不伴有关节炎且至少有其他三项低于95%置信区间上限的定义(AUC,0.897;敏感性,95.2%;特异性,84.1%)。
本研究首次提供了经皮肤科医生和患者认可的银屑病“最小疾病活动度”概念。MDA定义为无活动性关节炎且满足以下6项中的3项:瘙痒≤1/10;鳞屑≤2/10;发红≤2/10;可见度≤2/10;BSA≤2;DLQI≤2;且特殊部位无病变。从设计上看,这些领域代表了疾病影响。这个MDA定义可作为充分管理的一种衡量标准,并取代其他主观或受限的工具。