Agarwal Anubhav, Mann Carlyn, Abdella Engida, Mitiku Workie, Alebachew Abebe, Berman Peter
Global Health and Population Department, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, 677 Huntington Ave, Boston, MA, 02115, USA.
Present address: School of Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Ottawa, 600 Peter Morand Crescent, Ottawa, K1G 5Z3, ON, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2020 May 7;20(1):389. doi: 10.1186/s12913-020-05218-1.
Continued investment, especially from domestic financing, is needed for Ethiopia to achieve universal health coverage and a sustainable health system over time. Understanding costs of providing health services will assist the government to mobilize adequate resources for health, and to understand future costs of changes in quality of care, service provision scope, and potential decline in external resources. This study assessed costs per unit of service output, "unit costs", for government primary hospitals and health centers, and disease-specific services within each facility.
Quantitative and qualitative data were collected from 25 primary hospitals and 47 health centers across eight of the eleven regions of Ethiopia for 2013/14, and 2014/15 and 2015/16 but only for primary hospitals, and supplemented by other related health and financial institutions records. A top-down costing approach was used to estimate unit costs for each facility by department - inpatient, outpatient, maternal and child health, and delivery. A mixed-method approach was used for the disease-specific unit costs exempt from fees.
Health center median unit cost was 146 Ethiopian birr (ETB) (17 PPP$, 2012), the Delivery department had the highest median unit cost (647 ETB; 76 PPP$, 2012) and Outpatient department (OPD) had the lowest (124 ETB; 14 PPP$, 2012). Primary hospital median unit cost was 339 ETB (40 PPP$, 2012), with Inpatient department having the highest median unit cost (1288 ETB; 151 PPP$, 2012), while OPD was the lowest (252 ETB; 29 PPP$, 2012). Drugs and pharmaceutical supplies accounted for most of the costs for both facilities. Among the exempted services offered, tuberculosis and antiretroviral treatment are the costliest with median unit costs from 1091 to 1536 ETB (128-180 PPP$, 2012), with drugs and supplies accounting for almost 90% of the costs.
High unit costs of service provision could be indicative of underutilization of the primary health care system, coupled with inefficiencies associated with organization and delivery of health services. Data from this study are being used to assess efficiency and productivity among primary care facilities, facilitate premium setting for health insurance, and improve budgeting and allocating health resources for a more sustainable and effective primary health care system.
埃塞俄比亚需要持续投资,特别是来自国内融资的投资,以便随着时间推移实现全民健康覆盖和可持续的卫生系统。了解提供卫生服务的成本将有助于政府为卫生领域筹集充足资源,并了解护理质量、服务提供范围变化以及外部资源可能减少带来的未来成本。本研究评估了政府基层医院和卫生中心以及各机构内特定疾病服务的单位服务产出成本,即“单位成本”。
2013/14年度、2014/15年度和2015/16年度从埃塞俄比亚11个地区中的8个地区的25家基层医院和47个卫生中心收集了定量和定性数据,但仅针对基层医院,此外还补充了其他相关卫生和金融机构的记录。采用自上而下的成本核算方法,按部门(住院、门诊、妇幼保健和分娩)估算每个机构的单位成本。对于免费的特定疾病单位成本,采用了混合方法。
卫生中心的单位成本中位数为146埃塞俄比亚比尔(ETB)(2012年购买力平价为17美元),分娩部门的单位成本中位数最高(647埃塞俄比亚比尔;2012年购买力平价为76美元),门诊部门(OPD)最低(124埃塞俄比亚比尔;2012年购买力平价为14美元)。基层医院的单位成本中位数为339埃塞俄比亚比尔(2012年购买力平价为40美元),住院部门的单位成本中位数最高(1288埃塞俄比亚比尔;2012年购买力平价为151美元),而门诊部门最低(252埃塞俄比亚比尔;2012年购买力平价为29美元)。药品和医疗用品占两个机构成本的大部分。在所提供的免费服务中,结核病和抗逆转录病毒治疗成本最高,单位成本中位数为1091至1536埃塞俄比亚比尔(2012年购买力平价为128 - 180美元),药品和用品几乎占成本的90%。
服务提供的高单位成本可能表明初级卫生保健系统利用不足,同时存在与卫生服务组织和提供相关的低效率问题。本研究的数据正用于评估初级保健机构的效率和生产力,促进健康保险保费设定,并改善预算编制以及为更可持续和有效的初级卫生保健系统分配卫生资源。