Crevier-Sorbo Gabriel, Brunette-Clément Tristan, Medawar Edgar, Mathieu Francois, Morgan Benjamin R, Hachem Laureen, Fallah Aria, Weil Alexander G, Ibrahim George M
Faculty of Medicine McGill University Montreal QC Canada.
Faculty of Medicine University of Montreal Montreal QC Canada.
Epilepsia Open. 2020 Mar 2;5(2):190-197. doi: 10.1002/epi4.12384. eCollection 2020 Jun.
The global burden of pediatric epilepsy is disproportionately concentrated in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). However, little is known about the effectiveness of current treatment programs in this setting. We present the outcomes of children who were assessed and treated at the Clinique D'Épilepsie de Port-au-Prince (CLIDEP), the only pediatric epilepsy referral center in Haiti.
A 10-year retrospective review of children consecutively assessed and treated at CLIDEP was performed. The primary outcome was seizure control following treatment for epilepsy. The secondary outcome was an accurate determination of the diagnosis of epilepsy. A data-driven principle component regression (PCR) analysis was used to identify variables associated with outcomes of interest.
Of the 812 children referred for evaluation, most children (82%) underwent electroencephalography to investigate a possible epilepsy diagnosis. Very few children (7%) underwent cranial imaging. Although many patients were lost to follow-up (24%), most children who returned to clinic had less frequent seizures (51%) and compliance with medication was relatively high (79%). Using PCR, we identified a patient phenotype that was strongly associated with poor seizure control which had strong contributions from abnormal neurological examination, higher number of antiepileptic drugs, comorbid diagnoses, epileptic encephalopathy or epilepsy syndrome, and developmental delay. Head circumference also contributed to epilepsy outcomes in Haiti with smaller head sizes being associated with a poor seizure outcome. A dissociable phenotype of febrile seizures, suspected structural abnormality, epileptic encephalopathy or epilepsy syndrome, and higher seizure frequency was associated with a diagnosis of epilepsy.
We describe the current landscape of childhood epilepsy in Haiti with an emphasis on diagnosis, treatment and outcomes. The findings provide evidence for the effectiveness of programs aimed at the diagnosis and management of epilepsy in LMICs and may inform the allocation of resources and create more effective referral structures.
全球儿童癫痫负担不成比例地集中在低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs)。然而,目前在这种背景下治疗方案的有效性知之甚少。我们展示了在海地唯一的儿科癫痫转诊中心太子港癫痫诊所(CLIDEP)接受评估和治疗的儿童的治疗结果。
对在CLIDEP连续接受评估和治疗的儿童进行了为期10年的回顾性研究。主要结果是癫痫治疗后的发作控制情况。次要结果是准确确定癫痫诊断。采用数据驱动的主成分回归(PCR)分析来确定与感兴趣的结果相关的变量。
在812名被转诊进行评估的儿童中,大多数儿童(82%)接受了脑电图检查以调查可能的癫痫诊断。很少有儿童(7%)接受了头颅影像学检查。尽管许多患者失访(24%),但大多数返回诊所的儿童发作频率降低(51%),并且药物依从性相对较高(79%)。通过PCR,我们确定了一种与发作控制不佳密切相关的患者表型,其主要受异常神经系统检查、更多种类的抗癫痫药物、合并诊断、癫痫性脑病或癫痫综合征以及发育迟缓的影响。头围也对海地的癫痫治疗结果有影响,较小的头围与较差的发作结果相关。热性惊厥、疑似结构异常、癫痫性脑病或癫痫综合征以及较高的发作频率这种可分离的表型与癫痫诊断相关。
我们描述了海地儿童癫痫的现状,重点是诊断、治疗和结果。这些发现为旨在诊断和管理低收入和中等收入国家癫痫的项目的有效性提供了证据,并可能为资源分配提供参考,建立更有效的转诊结构。