Departamento de Ciencias Clínicas, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria. Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, España.
Servicio de Radiodiagnóstico, Complejo Hospitalario Universitario Insular Materno-Infantil. Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, España.
Cir Cir. 2020;88(4):420-427. doi: 10.24875/CIRU.20001719.
To assess whether the accuracy in locoregional staging using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in rectal cancer (primary or post-chemoradiotherapy) improves by adding diffusion-weighted imaging, according to the radiologist's degree of experience.
Retrospective study on 100 MRI records (1.5 T, 2011-2016) from patients with rectal cancer (reference standard: histology of surgical specimens). Ten radiologists (three experienced in rectal cancer, three specialized in other areas and four residents) individually reviewed each case twice: first, evaluating just high-resolution T2-weighted sequences; second, evaluation of diffusion-weighted plus high-resolution ones. The analysis focused on the differentiation between early (0-I) and advanced (II-IV) stages. Accuracy, sensitivity/specificity and predictive values were calculated.
Experienced radiologists showed some worsening by adding diffusion-weighted imaging, mainly at primary staging (accuracy: 0.769 to 0.701). Inexperienced radiologists presented a post-chemoradiotherapy improvement (accuracy: 0.574 to 0.642; specificity of 19.1 to 29.8%), although with no other remarkable changes. Residents demonstrated a worsening at primary staging by adding diffusion (accuracy: 0.670 to 0.633; specificity: 45.8 to 39.6%), but post-chemoradiotherapy improvement (sensitivity: 80.6 to 87%). The differences between both reviews were not statistically significant.
No significant differences were found in the distinction between early and advanced rectal tumors secondary to adding diffusion-weighted imaging to high-resolution T2-weighted sequences.
评估在直肠癌(原发或放化疗后)局部区域分期中,磁共振成像(MRI)的准确性是否因放射科医生的经验程度不同而通过添加扩散加权成像得到改善。
对 2011 年至 2016 年 100 例直肠癌患者的 100 份 MRI 记录(1.5T)进行回顾性研究(参考标准:手术标本的组织学)。10 名放射科医生(3 名专门从事直肠癌,3 名专门从事其他领域,4 名住院医师)分别两次独立检查每个病例:第一次,仅评估高分辨率 T2 加权序列;第二次,评估扩散加权加高分辨率序列。分析重点是区分早期(0-I)和晚期(II-IV)阶段。计算了准确性、敏感度/特异性和预测值。
经验丰富的放射科医生在添加扩散加权成像后显示出一些恶化,主要是在原发分期(准确性:0.769 降至 0.701)。经验不足的放射科医生在放化疗后出现改善(准确性:0.574 升至 0.642;特异性从 19.1%升至 29.8%),尽管没有其他显著变化。住院医师在添加扩散时,原发分期的准确性恶化(准确性:0.670 降至 0.633;特异性:45.8%降至 39.6%),但放化疗后改善(敏感度:80.6%升至 87%)。两次检查之间的差异没有统计学意义。
在高分辨率 T2 加权序列中添加扩散加权成像后,早期和晚期直肠肿瘤之间的区分没有显著差异。