Greydanus Dominique J, Hassmann Lyndsey L, Butler Frank K
J Spec Oper Med. 2020 Summer;20(2):95-103. doi: 10.55460/T63H-3OXX.
At present, however, there is no systematic, comprehensive quality assurance program for TCCC training throughout the DoD. Individual courses and instructors may or may not use all of the materials in the JTS-approved curriculum; they may or may not add content that is not part of the JTS curriculum; and they may or may not add additional training in the form of advanced simulation, hands-on training with moulaged casualties, graded trauma lanes, or live-tissue training. A recent pilot appraisal of four Tactical Combat Casualty Care for Medical Personnel (TCCC-MP) training courses found that TCCC-MP courses are not presenting all of the course material recommended by the Joint Trauma System (JTS), despite TCCC training having been mandated by the Department of Defense (DoD) for all US military personnel. Some of the omitted material is essential to ensuring that students are fully prepared to perform TCCC on the battlefield. Further, there was incorrect messaging presented in the TCCC-MP courses that were appraised, some of which, if actually reflected in the care provided on the battlefield, would likely result in adverse casualty outcomes. Other aspects of the TCCC messaging presented in the appraised courses that is not at present part of the JTS-approved curriculum might, however, be appropriate for inclusion into the TCCC Guidelines and the course curriculum. Examples of material that should be considered for incorporation into the TCCC curriculum include modifying the method of tranexamic acid (TXA) administration (slow IV push vs the currently recommended 10-minute infusion) and a better technique for securing of the new CAT Generation 7 tourniquets after application. The course appraiser also noted that there were a number of excellent videos of actual TCCC interventions being performed that are not part of the current JTS-approved TCCC-MP curriculum. These videos should be forwarded to CoTCCC staff and the Joint Trauma Education and Training (JTET) branch of the JTS for consideration as potential additions to the TCCC-MP curriculum. Consideration should also be given to the inclusion of additional TCCC training modalities such as advanced simulators, moulaged casualties, graded trauma lanes, autologous blood transfusion training, and the use of live-tissue training (when logistically feasible) for selected course items such as surgical airways. Further, the 16-hour training time currently allotted for TCCC-MP training was found to be insufficient to present all of academic material and testing contained in the existing TCCC-MP curriculum. A 5-day course should be considered to include the entire JTS-recommended curriculum and to add graded trauma lanes and autologous blood transfusion training to the core JTS TCCC-MP curriculum. The post-course written testing also needs to use the standardized TCCC fund of knowledge questions and the TCCC Critical Decision Case Study questions developed by the JTS. Finally, there is a need to establish a systematic and standardized quality assurance program to ensure that TCCC training programs are carried out in accordance with the JTS-recommended TCCC curriculum. This program would best be performed as a new function of the CoTCCC with dedicated TCCC course appraisers.
然而,目前国防部尚未针对战术战斗伤员护理(TCCC)培训制定系统、全面的质量保证计划。个别课程和教员可能会使用也可能不会使用联合创伤系统(JTS)批准课程中的所有材料;他们可能会添加也可能不会添加不属于JTS课程的内容;并且他们可能会添加也可能不会添加以高级模拟、模拟伤员实操训练、分级创伤通道或活体组织训练等形式的额外培训。最近对四门医疗人员战术战斗伤员护理(TCCC-MP)培训课程的试点评估发现,尽管国防部已要求所有美国军事人员接受TCCC培训,但TCCC-MP课程并未涵盖联合创伤系统(JTS)推荐的所有课程材料。一些被遗漏的材料对于确保学员为在战场上实施TCCC做好充分准备至关重要。此外,在接受评估的TCCC-MP课程中存在错误信息,其中一些如果实际反映在战场上提供的护理中,可能会导致不良的伤员救治结果。然而,在接受评估的课程中呈现的TCCC信息的其他方面,目前并非JTS批准课程的一部分,可能适合纳入TCCC指南和课程设置。应考虑纳入TCCC课程的材料示例包括改变氨甲环酸(TXA)的给药方法(缓慢静脉推注与目前推荐的10分钟输注)以及应用后固定新一代CAT 7型止血带的更好技术。课程评估人员还指出,有一些实际进行TCCC干预的优秀视频,它们并非当前JTS批准的TCCC-MP课程的一部分。这些视频应转发给联合战术战斗伤员护理协调小组(CoTCCC)工作人员以及JTS的联合创伤教育与培训(JTET)部门,以供考虑作为TCCC-MP课程的潜在补充内容。还应考虑纳入其他TCCC培训方式,如高级模拟器、模拟伤员、分级创伤通道、自体输血培训,以及在后勤可行时针对选定课程项目(如手术气道)使用活体组织训练。此外,目前分配给TCCC-MP培训的16小时培训时间被发现不足以呈现现有TCCC-MP课程中的所有学术材料和测试内容。应考虑开设为期5天的课程,以纳入JTS推荐的全部课程,并在核心JTS TCCC-MP课程中增加分级创伤通道和自体输血培训。课程后的书面测试还需要使用JTS制定的标准化TCCC知识题库和TCCC关键决策案例研究问题。最后,需要建立一个系统、标准化的质量保证计划,以确保TCCC培训计划按照JTS推荐的TCCC课程进行。该计划最好作为CoTCCC的一项新职能,由专门的TCCC课程评估人员执行。