Terrizzi Brandon F, Woodward Amanda M, Beier Jonathan S
Division of General and Community Pediatrics, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH 45229, USA.
Department of Psychology, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA.
J Exp Child Psychol. 2020 Oct;198:104867. doi: 10.1016/j.jecp.2020.104867. Epub 2020 Jul 3.
In hierarchical societies, what do we expect from people at the top? Early in life, children use horizontal relationships (e.g., affiliation) to predict selectivity in others' prosocial behavior. But it is unknown whether children also view asymmetries in prosocial behavior as characteristic of vertical relationships (e.g., differences in social power). In two experiments, we investigated 4- to 7-year-old children's and adults' (N = 192) intuitions about links among relative authority status, helpful action, and unhelpful inaction. In Experiment 1, participants at all ages viewed a character who chose not to help another person as holding a position of authority over them; participants also viewed this unhelpful character as being less nice than the person in need. However, no age group made consistent inferences about the relative authority of a helper and a helpee. In Experiment 2, children had mixed intuitions when separately predicting whether high- and low-authority characters would be helpful in the future. However, older children and adults consistently indicated that a subordinate would be more likely than an authority to help a third party. These findings establish that children's social theories include expectations for links between power and prosociality by at least the preschool years. Whereas some judgments in this domain are stable from 4 years of age onward, others emerge gradually. Whether consistent responses occurred early or only later in development, however, all measures converged on a single intuition: People more easily associate authority with indifference to others' needs.
在等级社会中,我们对处于顶层的人有什么期望?在幼年时期,儿童会利用横向关系(例如归属感)来预测他人亲社会行为中的选择性。但尚不清楚儿童是否也将亲社会行为中的不对称视为纵向关系的特征(例如社会权力差异)。在两项实验中,我们调查了4至7岁儿童和成年人(N = 192)对相对权威地位、帮助行为和不帮助行为之间联系的直觉。在实验1中,所有年龄段的参与者都认为一个选择不帮助他人的角色对他们拥有权威地位;参与者还认为这个不帮忙的角色不如有需要的人友善。然而,没有一个年龄组对帮助者和被帮助者的相对权威做出一致的推断。在实验2中,当分别预测高权威和低权威角色未来是否会提供帮助时,儿童的直觉不一。然而,年龄较大的儿童和成年人一致表示,下属比权威更有可能帮助第三方。这些发现表明,至少在学龄前儿童的社会理论中就包括了对权力和亲社会性之间联系 的期望。虽然该领域的一些判断从4岁起就很稳定,但其他判断是逐渐出现的。然而,无论一致的反应是在早期还是在发展后期出现,所有测量结果都指向了一种单一的直觉:人们更容易将权威与对他人需求的冷漠联系起来。