Sovaila Silvia, Purcarea Adrian, Froissart Antoine, Ranque Brigitte, Kieffer Pierre, Andres Emmanuel, Goujard Cecile, Weber Jean-Christophe, Bergmann Jean-François, Gayet Stephane, Granel Brigitte, Bourgarit Anne
Internal Medicine Department, Civil Hospital, University Hospital of Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France.
Internal Medicine Department, University Hospital Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France.
J Med Life. 2020 Apr-Jun;13(2):183-186. doi: 10.25122/jml-2020-1003.
Clinical reasoning is the cornerstone of medical practice, and achieving this competence depends on a large number of factors. Internal medicine departments provide junior doctors with plentiful and varied patients, offering a comprehensive basis for learning clinical reasoning. In order to evaluate the usefulness of an early rotation at internal medicine departments, we compared, via script concordance tests, the evolution of residents' clinical reasoning after an initial internal medicine rotation compared to rotations through other medical specialties. Twenty-two residents were tested after six months of their internal medicine rotation and compared to twenty-five residents that had the first rotation in another specialty (control). We showed a significant difference in the improvement of the script concordance tests scores (p=0.015) between the beginning and the end of their first rotation between the internal medicine and the control groups, and this implies the lower improvement of clinical reasoning skills and spontaneous learning slope of the junior doctors in other departments.
临床推理是医疗实践的基石,而获得这种能力取决于大量因素。内科科室为初级医生提供了丰富多样的患者,为学习临床推理提供了全面的基础。为了评估早期在内科科室轮转的效用,我们通过脚本一致性测试,比较了住院医师在内科初始轮转后与在其他医学专科轮转后临床推理能力的演变情况。在内科轮转六个月后,对22名住院医师进行了测试,并与25名首次在其他专科轮转的住院医师(对照组)进行了比较。我们发现,内科组和对照组在首次轮转开始和结束时,脚本一致性测试分数的提高存在显著差异(p = 0.015),这意味着其他科室初级医生的临床推理技能提高幅度较小,自发学习斜率较低。