Blakeney Erin Abu-Rish, Bekemeier Betty, Zierler Brenda K
University of Washington School of Nursing.
Race Soc Probl. 2020 Jun;12(2):87-102. doi: 10.1007/s12552-019-09272-1. Epub 2020 Jan 1.
The purpose of this study was to explore relationships between the Great Recession in the United States and maternal and child health (MCH) disparities in prenatal care, birth weight, gestational age, and infant mortality. Using annual, 2005-2011 individual-level Washington (WA) and Florida (FL) birth certificate data, we analyzed MCH outcome rates and disparities among subpopulation component groups (e.g., subpopulation 'maternal ethnicity' divided into component groups such as non-Hispanic White, non-Hispanic Black). We focused on whether disparities widened during two recession periods: Period 1 (December 2007-June 2009-official dates of Great Recession) and Period 2 (January 2010-December 2011) and compared these to a Baseline Period 0 (January 2005-March 2007). Subpopulations (n=14) and component groups (n=47) were identified a priori. Results indicate that disparities widened on at least one MCH outcome for 22 component groups in WA during Period 1 and 37 component groups during Period 2, compared to baseline. In FL, disparities widened for 25 component groups during Period 1 and 31 during Period 2. Disparities increased in both periods on the same outcomes for 11 WA component groups and 7 component groups in FL. Disparity increases tended to cluster among those with young age, low education, and among members of minority race/ethnicity groups-particularly Black mothers. Findings support hypothesized relationships between expected increases in need during the Great Recession, and worsening MCH outcomes and disparities. Compared to baseline, there were more disparity increases in Period 2 than 1. Additional research regarding specific factors influencing changes in disparities are needed.
本研究的目的是探讨美国大衰退与产前护理、出生体重、孕周和婴儿死亡率方面的母婴健康(MCH)差异之间的关系。利用2005 - 2011年华盛顿州(WA)和佛罗里达州(FL)的年度个体层面出生证明数据,我们分析了亚人群组成组(例如,亚人群“母亲种族”分为非西班牙裔白人、非西班牙裔黑人等组成组)中的母婴健康结局率和差异。我们关注在两个衰退期差异是否扩大:第1期(2007年12月 - 2009年6月——大衰退的官方日期)和第2期(2010年1月 - 2011年12月),并将这些与基线期0(2005年1月 - 2007年3月)进行比较。预先确定了亚人群(n = 14)和组成组(n = 47)。结果表明,与基线相比,在第1期华盛顿州有22个组成组、在第2期有37个组成组的至少一项母婴健康结局的差异扩大。在佛罗里达州,第1期有25个组成组、第2期有31个组成组的差异扩大。华盛顿州的11个组成组和佛罗里达州的7个组成组在两个时期相同结局的差异均增加。差异增加往往集中在年龄小、教育程度低以及少数种族/族裔群体成员——尤其是黑人母亲之中。研究结果支持了大衰退期间需求预期增加与母婴健康结局及差异恶化之间的假设关系。与基线相比,第2期差异增加的情况比第1期更多。需要针对影响差异变化的具体因素开展更多研究。