Centre for Forensic Science, Department of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Health & Life Sciences, Northumbria University Newcastle, Ellison Building, NE1 8ST, Newcastle Upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
Centre for Forensic Science, Department of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Health & Life Sciences, Northumbria University Newcastle, Ellison Building, NE1 8ST, Newcastle Upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
Forensic Sci Int. 2020 Oct;315:110432. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2020.110432. Epub 2020 Aug 14.
Interpretation of fibre evidence at activity level requires extensive knowledge of all the possible transfer mechanisms that may explain the presence of fibres on a recipient surface of interest. Herein, we investigate a transfer method that has been largely understudied in previous literature: contactless transfer between garments through airborne travel. Volunteers were asked to wear UV-luminescent garments composed of different textile materials and situate themselves in a semi-enclosed space (elevator) for a pre-determined period of time with other participants, who wore non-luminescent recipient garments. The latter were then inspected for fibres using UV-luminescent photographic techniques. Results showed that contactless transfer between garments is possible. Indeed, a number of fibres were observed after most of the experiments. As many as 66 and 38 fibres were observed in the experiments involving cotton and polyester donor garments, compared to 2 and 1 fibres in those involving acrylic and wool donor garments, respectively. In this regard, the type of donor garment was found to be a significant factor. Multifactorial ANOVA supported these observations (p<0.001) and further indicated a statistically significant influence of elevator door opening/closing (p<0.001), people entering/exiting (p=0.078) and the recipient garment (p=0.030). Therefore, contactless transfer of fibres between garments can occur and can do so in (ostensibly) high numbers. This should be taken into consideration when interpreting fibre evidence at activity level and may have a major implication for the assignment of evidential values in some specific cases.
在活动层面解释纤维证据需要广泛了解所有可能的转移机制,这些机制可以解释纤维在感兴趣的受体表面上的存在。在此,我们研究了一种在先前文献中研究甚少的转移方法:通过空气传播在衣物之间进行无接触转移。志愿者被要求穿着由不同纺织材料组成的紫外线发光服装,并在半封闭空间(电梯)中与其他穿着非发光受体服装的参与者一起停留一段时间。然后,使用紫外线发光摄影技术检查受体服装上是否有纤维。结果表明,衣物之间的无接触转移是可能的。事实上,在大多数实验之后,观察到了一些纤维。在涉及棉和聚酯供体服装的实验中,观察到多达 66 和 38 根纤维,而在涉及丙烯酸和羊毛供体服装的实验中,分别观察到 2 和 1 根纤维。在这方面,供体服装的类型被发现是一个重要因素。多因素方差分析支持了这些观察结果(p<0.001),并进一步表明电梯门的打开/关闭(p<0.001)、人员进出(p=0.078)和受体服装(p=0.030)具有统计学意义的影响。因此,纤维可以在衣物之间进行无接触转移,并且可以以(表面上)高数量进行转移。在活动层面解释纤维证据时应考虑到这一点,并且在某些特定情况下,可能对证据价值的赋值产生重大影响。