Assessment of technical heterogeneity among diagnostic tests to detect germline risk variants for hematopoietic malignancies.

PURPOSE

To determine the degree of testing consistency among commercially available diagnostic assays for hereditary hematopoietic malignancies (HHMs).

METHODS

Next-generation sequencing assays designed for the diagnosis of HHMs were studied to determine which genes were sequenced, their ability to detect variant types relevant for HHMs, and clinical-grade characteristics such as price, turnaround time, and tissue types accepted.

RESULTS

Commercial assays varied in price (USD 250-4702), number of genes sequenced (12-73), and average turnaround time (14-42 days). A number of nongermline tissue types were accepted despite the tests being designed for germline diagnostic purposes. Multiple genes with well-characterized roles in HHM pathogenesis were omitted from more than one-third of panels intended for the evaluation of HHMs. Only 4 of 82 genes were consistently covered across all HHM diagnostic panels. The assays were highly variable in their sensitivity for structural alterations relevant to HHMs, such as copy-number variants.

CONCLUSION

A high degree of diagnostic heterogeneity exists among commercially available HHM diagnostic assays. Many of these assays are incapable of detecting the full spectrum of HHM-associated variants, leaving patients vulnerable to the consequences of underdiagnosis, missed opportunities for screening, and the potential for donor-derived malignancies.