Likosky W H
Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program, Santa Clara, CA 95051.
Neurology. 1988 Jul;38(7 Suppl 2):14-8.
Neurologists in the Kaiser-Permanente Medical Care Program recently designed a study to evaluate the utility of intensive immunosuppression with cyclophosphamide compared with folic acid in 44 patients with chronic progressive multiple sclerosis (MS). Although preliminary results based on incomplete data suggest cyclophosphamide may be safely administered in an outpatient clinic setting and modest benefits cannot be ruled out, it is doubtful that there are very substantial benefits to that therapy. Although several other studies have been cited as evidence of cyclophosphamide's favorable effect on the clinical course of patients with MS, many of these studies have had design shortcomings. If these flaws are considered, the hypothesis that cyclophosphamide has a favorable effect on the course of MS must be considered weak.
凯撒医疗保健计划的神经科医生最近设计了一项研究,以评估44例慢性进行性多发性硬化症(MS)患者中,环磷酰胺强化免疫抑制与叶酸相比的效用。尽管基于不完整数据的初步结果表明,环磷酰胺可在门诊环境中安全给药,且不能排除有适度益处,但该疗法是否有非常显著的益处仍值得怀疑。尽管其他几项研究被引为环磷酰胺对MS患者临床病程有有利影响的证据,但其中许多研究存在设计缺陷。如果考虑这些缺陷,那么环磷酰胺对MS病程有有利影响这一假设必定站不住脚。