Han Xinxin, Li Xiaotong, Cheng Liang, Wu Zhuoqing, Zhu Jiming
School of Medicine, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China.
Institute for Hospital Management, Tsinghua Shenzhen International Graduate School, Shenzhen, China.
BMC Med Educ. 2020 Sep 17;20(1):314. doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-02234-x.
To evaluate the performance of China's new medical licensing examination (MLE) for rural general practice, which determines the number of qualified doctors who can provide primary care for China's rural residents, and to identify associated factors.
Data came from all 547 examinees of the 2017 MLE for rural general practice in Hainan province, China. Overall pass rates of the MLE and pass rates of the MLE Step 1 practical skills examination and Step 2 written exam were examined. Chi-square tests and multivariable logistic regression were used to identify examinee characteristics associated with passing Step 1 and Step 2, respectively.
Of the 547 examinees, 68% passed Step 1, while only 23% of Step 1 passers passed Step 2, yielding an 15% (82 of 547) overall pass rate of the whole examination. Junior college medical graduates were 2.236 (95% CI, 1.127-4.435) times more likely to pass Step 1 than secondary school medical graduates. Other characteristics, including age, gender, forms of study and years of graduation, were also significantly associated with passing Step 1. In contrast, examinees' vocational school major and Step 1 score were the only two significant predictors of passing Step 2.
Our study reveals a low pass rate of China's new MLE for rural general practice in Hainan province, indicating a relatively weak competency of graduates from China's alternative medical education. An effective long-term solution might be to improve examinees' clinical competency through mandating residency training for graduates of China's alternative medical education.
评估中国农村全科医学新执业医师资格考试(MLE)的表现,该考试决定了能够为中国农村居民提供初级医疗服务的合格医生数量,并确定相关因素。
数据来自中国海南省2017年农村全科医学执业医师资格考试的所有547名考生。检查了执业医师资格考试的总体通过率以及第一步实践技能考试和第二步笔试的通过率。分别使用卡方检验和多变量逻辑回归来确定与通过第一步和第二步相关的考生特征。
在547名考生中,68%通过了第一步,而第一步通过者中只有23%通过了第二步,整个考试的总体通过率为15%(547人中的82人)。大专医学毕业生通过第一步的可能性是中专医学毕业生的2.236倍(95%可信区间,1.127 - 4.435)。其他特征,包括年龄、性别、学习形式和毕业年限,也与通过第一步显著相关。相比之下,考生的职业学校专业和第一步成绩是通过第二步的仅有的两个显著预测因素。
我们的研究揭示了中国海南省农村全科医学新执业医师资格考试的低通过率,表明中国替代医学教育的毕业生能力相对较弱。一个有效的长期解决方案可能是通过强制中国替代医学教育的毕业生接受住院医师培训来提高考生的临床能力。