Janssen Hella, Maat Arija, Slot Margot I E, Scheepers Floortje
Department of Psychiatry, Brain Center Rudolf Magnus, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
GGzE, Institute for Mental Health Care Eindhoven and De Kempen, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
Early Interv Psychiatry. 2021 Aug;15(4):1019-1027. doi: 10.1111/eip.13048. Epub 2020 Sep 17.
Early detection and intervention in individuals at risk for developing psychosis have become a priority for many clinical services around the world. Limited naturalistic evidence is available on whether detection and intervention for ultra-high risk (UHR) is effective by means of reducing psychosis risk and improving functioning.
We compared functioning scores over 5.9 (±7.7) months of time between UHR individuals (n = 61) and help-seeking adolescents without a specific UHR profile (general adolescent help-seeking population [HSP]; n = 82) aged 12 to 25 years receiving psychological interventions at a specialized UHR service in the Netherlands. Attenuated psychotic symptoms (APS) were evaluated over time within the UHR group. In addition, the impact of duration of treatment, <7 sessions, 8 to 21 sessions and >20 sessions, as well as treatment type, that is, cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) and CBT + add on treatment, were evaluated.
Both UHR and HSP showed an increase in functioning over time (P < .001), with no difference between these groups. The UHR group showed a reduction of APS over time (P < .001). More than 20 treatment sessions was more effective than 1 to 6 treatment sessions (P < .01, partial eta squared = .08) and CBT was equally effective as CBT-add on in improving functioning.
The findings of this study suggest that psychological treatment is just as effective in improving functioning in UHR as in HSP. Moreover, it decreases APS in UHR. Improvement in functioning is not affected by treatment type, but positively affected by the duration of treatment.
对有患精神病风险的个体进行早期检测和干预已成为全球许多临床服务的首要任务。关于超高风险(UHR)检测和干预能否通过降低精神病风险及改善功能发挥作用,现有自然主义证据有限。
我们比较了荷兰一家专门的UHR服务机构中,年龄在12至25岁之间接受心理干预的UHR个体(n = 61)和无特定UHR特征的求助青少年(一般青少年求助人群[HSP];n = 82)在5.9(±7.7)个月时间内的功能评分。对UHR组随时间评估亚临床精神病性症状(APS)。此外,还评估了治疗时长(<7次、8至21次和>20次)以及治疗类型(即认知行为疗法[CBT]和CBT加附加治疗)的影响。
UHR组和HSP组的功能随时间均有所改善(P <.001),两组之间无差异。UHR组的APS随时间减少(P <.001)。超过20次治疗比1至6次治疗更有效(P <.01,偏 eta 平方 = 0.08),且CBT在改善功能方面与CBT加附加治疗同样有效。
本研究结果表明,心理治疗在改善UHR个体功能方面与HSP个体同样有效。此外,它可降低UHR个体的APS。功能改善不受治疗类型影响,但受治疗时长的积极影响。