School of Medicine, The Royal College of Surgeons, Dublin, Ireland.
Department of Surgery, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada.
Dig Surg. 2020;37(6):480-487. doi: 10.1159/000510383. Epub 2020 Sep 24.
Recent studies suggest that nonoperative management of appendicitis (NOMA) may be a reasonable option for managing uncomplicated acute appendicitis. We examined the Internet to see if patients are likely to find the information they need to make an informed decision between the 2 options.
A list of 29 search terms was established by a focus group and then entered into Google, resulting in 49 unique webpages, each reviewed by 3 reviewers. Consensus was obtained for bias (surgery, NOMA, or balanced), webpage type, JAMA score, reading grade, and DISCERN score, a measure of quality of written information for patients.
Thirty of the 49 websites (61%) favored surgery, while 13 (27%) favored NOMA, and 6 sites (12%) provided balanced information. Twelve of 49 sites (24%) did not list NOMA as an option. The majority of patient-directed (11/12 = 92%) and physician-directed (7/9 = 78%) webpages favored surgery, whereas academic webpages presented a more balanced distribution. Academic and physician-directed webpages ranked higher than commercial and news webpages (median ranks 3 and 4 vs. 7.5 and 8). Only 8/49 sites (16%) mentioned that the presence of a fecalith predicts the failure of NOMA. Reading grades were almost all well above the recommended grade 8 level.
Most of the webpages available on the Internet do not provide enough information, nor are they sufficiently understandable to allow most patients to make an informed decision about the current options for the management of acute appendicitis.
最近的研究表明,对于单纯性急性阑尾炎,非手术治疗(NOMA)可能是一种合理的选择。我们在互联网上进行了检索,以了解患者是否能够找到做出这两种选择所需的信息。
一个焦点小组制定了一份包含 29 个搜索词的清单,然后将其输入谷歌,得到 49 个唯一的网页,每个网页都由 3 名评审员进行审查。对于偏向性(手术、NOMA 或平衡)、网页类型、JAMA 评分、阅读等级和 DISCERN 评分(患者书面信息质量的衡量标准),评审员达成了共识。
在 49 个网站中,有 30 个(61%)支持手术,13 个(27%)支持 NOMA,6 个(12%)提供了平衡的信息。在 49 个网站中,有 12 个(24%)没有将 NOMA 列为选择方案。大多数面向患者(11/12=92%)和医生(7/9=78%)的网页支持手术,而学术网页则提供了更平衡的分布。学术和医生指导的网页排名高于商业和新闻网页(中位数分别为 3 和 4 与 7.5 和 8)。只有 8/49 个网站(16%)提到粪石的存在预示着 NOMA 的失败。阅读等级几乎都远高于建议的 8 级水平。
互联网上提供的大多数网页没有提供足够的信息,也没有足够的易懂性,无法让大多数患者对当前治疗急性阑尾炎的选择做出明智的决策。