Pryweller Jennifer R, Baughman Brandon C, Frasier Samuel D, O'Conor Ellen C, Pandhi Abhi, Wang Jiajing, Morrison Aimee A, Tsao Jack W
Department of Neurology, College of Medicine, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Memphis, TN, United States.
Semmes Murphey Clinic, Memphis, TN, United States.
Front Neurol. 2020 Sep 2;11:839. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2020.00839. eCollection 2020.
Nearly 380,000 U.S. service members between 2000 and 2017 were, and at least 300,000 athletes annually are, diagnosed with concussion. It is imperative to establish a gold-standard diagnostic test to quickly and accurately diagnose concussion. In this non-randomized, prospective study, we examined the reliability and validity of a novel neurocognitive assessment tool, the Defense Automated Neurobehavioral Assessment (DANA), designed to be a more sensitive, yet efficient, measure of concussion symptomatology. In this study, the DANA Brief version was compared to an established measure of concussion screening, the Military Acute Concussion Evaluation (MACE), in a group of non-concussed service members. DANA Brief subtests demonstrated low to moderate reliability, as measured by intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC; values range: 0.28-0.58), which is comparable to other computerized neurocognitive tests that are widely-implemented to diagnose concussion. Statistically significant associations were found between learning and memory components of the DANA Brief and the diagnostic MACE cognitive test score (DANA Brief subtests: CDD: = 0.05, = 0.023; CDS: = 0.10, = 0.010). However, a more robust relationship was found between DANA Brief components involving attention and working memory, including immediate memory, and the MACE cognitive test score (DANA Brief subtests: GNG: = 0.08, = 0.003; PRO: = 0.08, = 0.002). These results provide evidence that the DANA Rapid version, a 5-min assessment self-administered on a hand-held portable device, based on the DANA Brief version, may serve as a clinically useful and improved neurocognitive concussion screen to minimize the time between injury and diagnosis in settings where professional medical evaluation may be unavailable or delayed. The DANA's portability, durability, shorter test time and lack of need for a medical professional to diagnose concussion overcome these critical limitations of the MACE.
2000年至2017年间,近38万美国军人被诊断患有脑震荡,而且每年至少有30万运动员被诊断患有脑震荡。因此,必须建立一种金标准诊断测试,以便快速、准确地诊断脑震荡。在这项非随机前瞻性研究中,我们检验了一种新型神经认知评估工具——国防自动化神经行为评估(DANA)的可靠性和有效性,该工具旨在更敏感且高效地测量脑震荡症状。在本研究中,将DANA简版与一种既定的脑震荡筛查方法——军事急性脑震荡评估(MACE),在一组未患脑震荡的军人中进行了比较。DANA简版子测试的可靠性较低至中等,以组内相关系数(ICC;取值范围:0.28 - 0.58)衡量,这与其他广泛用于诊断脑震荡的计算机化神经认知测试相当。在DANA简版的学习和记忆部分与诊断性MACE认知测试分数之间发现了具有统计学意义的关联(DANA简版子测试:CDD: = 0.05, = 0.023;CDS: = 0.10, = 0.010)。然而,在DANA简版中涉及注意力和工作记忆(包括即时记忆)的部分与MACE认知测试分数之间发现了更强的关系(DANA简版子测试:GNG: = 0.08, = 0.003;PRO: = 0.08, = 0.002)。这些结果表明,基于DANA简版的DANA快速版(一种可在手持便携式设备上自行进行的5分钟评估),可作为一种临床有用且经过改进的神经认知脑震荡筛查工具,以在可能无法获得或延迟专业医学评估的情况下,尽量缩短受伤与诊断之间的时间。DANA的便携性、耐用性、较短的测试时间以及无需医学专业人员进行脑震荡诊断,克服了MACE的这些关键局限性。