Zhang Ni, Drake Stacy A, Ding Kele
San Jose State University, San Jose, CA, United States.
Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2020 Sep 28;4(9):e16800. doi: 10.2196/16800.
Adolescents and young adults demonstrate the highest rate of unrestrained motor vehicle fatalities, making the promotion of seat belt restraint a priority for public health practitioners. Because social media use among adolescents and young adults has proliferated in recent years, it is critical to explore how to use this tool to promote seat belt use among this population. Social media posts can contain various types of information within each post and this information can be communicated using different modalities.
In this study, based on the elaboration likelihood model, we aimed to examine how adolescents and young adults reacted to different appeals in various components of posts in the pilot of a promotion intervention on the Instagram BuckleUp4Life account.
Using thematic analysis, we examined different appeals in 3 components (photo, text, and caption) of 199 posts in BuckleUp4Life and compared the number of likes for different appeals.
We found that 6 appeals were used in the posts: rational, ego, social, fun, positive emotional, and fear appeals. The results of our study showed that in photos, fun appeals were the most popular. Rational and positive emotional appeals were the most appealing in text and captions. Regardless of the location of the components (photo, text, or captions), rational appeal was the most popular appeal.
Based on the findings of our study, we recommend that public health practitioners utilize fun photos with rational and positive emotional appeals in text and captions rather than fear or social appeals, when promoting seat belt use through social media, especially Instagram.
青少年和青年的机动车无约束死亡率最高,因此促进安全带使用成为公共卫生从业者的首要任务。近年来,青少年和青年使用社交媒体的现象激增,探索如何利用这一工具促进该人群使用安全带至关重要。社交媒体帖子在每个帖子中都可能包含各种类型的信息,并且这些信息可以通过不同的方式进行传达。
在本研究中,基于精细加工可能性模型,我们旨在研究在Instagram的“BuckleUp4Life”账户上进行的一项促进干预试点中,青少年和青年对帖子各组成部分中不同诉求的反应。
我们采用主题分析方法,研究了“BuckleUp4Life”中199个帖子的三个组成部分(照片、文字和说明文字)中的不同诉求,并比较了不同诉求的点赞数。
我们发现帖子中使用了六种诉求:理性诉求、自我诉求、社交诉求、趣味诉求、积极情感诉求和恐惧诉求。我们的研究结果表明,在照片中,趣味诉求最受欢迎。理性诉求和积极情感诉求在文字和说明文字中最具吸引力。无论组成部分位于何处(照片、文字或说明文字),理性诉求都是最受欢迎的诉求。
基于我们的研究结果,我们建议公共卫生从业者在通过社交媒体,尤其是Instagram推广安全带使用时,在文字和说明文字中使用带有理性和积极情感诉求的趣味照片,而不是恐惧诉求或社交诉求。