Patel Shiv J, Zhang Theodore, Harrington Melvyn A
Joseph Barnhart Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas.
Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent). 2020 Jul 22;33(4):560-565. doi: 10.1080/08998280.2020.1789380.
Orthopedic surgery residency applicants often turn to data from many online ranking platforms to select programs. The purpose of this study was to determine if programs belonging to different Doximity ranking groups and US geographical regions favor certain applicant characteristics in order to give prospective residents more data to make informed application decisions. 2019 Doximity rankings and matched applicant data from the 2019 Association of American Medical Colleges Residency Navigator were collected and used to determine differences among matched applicant characteristics in Doximity ranking groups and US regions. Matched applicants from the top Doximity ranking group had, on average, significantly more peer-reviewed publications than those of any other ranking group. Among US regions, matched applicants in South Atlantic programs had, on average, significantly fewer peer-reviewed publications than those in Mid Atlantic programs. Residents at South Atlantic programs spent a significantly higher percentage of their first-year training in ambulatory community settings than those in Mid Atlantic, Pacific, or East North Central programs. In conclusion, Doximity ranking is associated with certain applicant qualities more than others, and applicants can use the information in this study to strategically apply to institutions with similar training and educational goals.
骨科手术住院医师项目申请人常常借助许多在线排名平台的数据来选择项目。本研究的目的是确定属于不同Doximity排名组以及美国不同地理区域的项目是否青睐某些申请人特征,以便为未来的住院医师提供更多数据,使其能够做出明智的申请决定。收集了2019年Doximity排名以及来自2019年美国医学院协会住院医师导航器的匹配申请人数据,并用于确定Doximity排名组和美国各地区中匹配申请人特征之间的差异。Doximity排名最高组的匹配申请人平均拥有的同行评审出版物显著多于其他任何排名组。在美国各地区中,南大西洋项目的匹配申请人平均拥有的同行评审出版物显著少于中大西洋项目。南大西洋项目的住院医师第一年在门诊社区环境中接受培训的比例显著高于中大西洋、太平洋或东中北部项目。总之,Doximity排名与某些申请人素质的关联程度高于其他素质,申请人可以利用本研究中的信息,有策略地申请具有相似培训和教育目标的机构。