Sundwall David N, Munger Mark A, Tak Casey R, Walsh Mike, Feehan Michael
Department of Family and Preventative Medicine, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.
Department of Pharmacotherapy, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.
Health Equity. 2020 Oct 7;4(1):430-437. doi: 10.1089/heq.2020.0009. eCollection 2020.
The rate of safety harm self-perceived medical errors and harms reported in the U.S. ambulatory system is not well characterized. To determine the prevalence of U.S. adult ambulatory care patient self-perceived safety harms and to gauge the degree of association between harms with various patient characteristics and outcomes. A large U.S. cross-sectional online survey of 9206 ambulatory care adults was assessed for their perception of medical errors and harms during care (misdiagnosis, mistakes in care, and wrong or delayed treatment) and also included patient demographics, health status, comorbidities, insurance status, income, barriers to care (affordability, transportation, and family and social support), number of visits to primary health care services in the past 12 months, and use of urgent or emergency care in the last 12 months. The overall rate of self-perceived medical errors and harms among adult patients in the ambulatory care setting was 36%. Female patients, independent of age, and those with multiple comorbidities or barriers to care, reported the highest number of medical errors. Utilization of multiple providers was associated with a greater number of reported medical errors, often resulting in changing health care providers. Patients who reported having trouble affording health care or navigating the system to receive care also reported higher levels of harm. They were cared for by multiple providers, often switch providers, and their care is associated with greater utilization of health care resources. Patients reporting the highest rates of harm had greater use of hospital and emergency room care. This large U.S. adult ambulatory care study provides evidence that patient self-perceived medical errors and harms reported by patients are common. Patient self-perceived medical errors and harms occur most commonly in women, with poor health, limitation of activities, and who have three or more comorbidities.
美国门诊系统中自我感知到的医疗差错和伤害发生率尚未得到充分描述。为了确定美国成年门诊患者自我感知到的安全伤害发生率,并衡量这些伤害与各种患者特征及结果之间的关联程度。对9206名成年门诊患者进行了一项大型美国横断面在线调查,评估他们在就医过程中对医疗差错和伤害的感知(误诊、护理失误以及错误或延迟治疗),调查还包括患者的人口统计学特征、健康状况、合并症、保险状况、收入、就医障碍(可负担性、交通以及家庭和社会支持)、过去12个月内到初级医疗服务机构就诊的次数,以及过去12个月内使用紧急或急诊护理的情况。门诊环境中成年患者自我感知到的医疗差错和伤害的总体发生率为36%。独立于年龄的女性患者以及患有多种合并症或存在就医障碍的患者报告的医疗差错数量最多。使用多个医疗服务提供者与报告的更多医疗差错相关,这通常导致更换医疗服务提供者。报告在支付医疗费用或在系统中获取护理方面存在困难的患者也报告了更高程度的伤害。他们由多个医疗服务提供者护理,经常更换提供者,并且他们的护理与更多的医疗资源利用相关。报告伤害发生率最高的患者更多地使用医院和急诊室护理。这项大型美国成年门诊护理研究提供了证据,证明患者自我感知到的医疗差错和伤害很常见。患者自我感知到的医疗差错和伤害最常发生在女性身上,这些女性健康状况不佳、活动受限且患有三种或更多合并症。