发育性语言障碍双语儿童对西班牙语介词和介词短语的实时理解:一项基于眼动证据的研究。
Real-time comprehension of Spanish prepositions and prepositional locutions in bilingual children with developmental language disorder: A study based on eye-movement evidence.
作者信息
Christou Spyros, Sanz-Torrent Monica, Coloma Carmen J, Guerra Ernesto, Araya Claudia, Andreu Llorenç
机构信息
Faculty of Psychology, Universitat de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Faculty of Medicine, Universidad de Chile, Santiago, Chile.
出版信息
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2021 Jan;56(1):51-71. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.12581. Epub 2020 Oct 28.
BACKGROUND
Function words, and more specifically prepositions and prepositional locutions, are considered to be one of the most important difficulties for children with DLD.
AIMS
To examine the capacity of bilingual children with developmental language disorder (DLD) to comprehend different Spanish prepositions and prepositional locutions in a simple sentence structure, for example, El gato está sobre la mesa/El gato está bajo la mesa (The cat is on the table/The cat is under the table).
METHODS & PROCEDURES: We used simple sentence structures to reduce lexical difficulties in order to focus our evaluation strictly on the grammatical morphemes under study. A total of 96 Spanish and Catalan-speaking participants, divided into four groups, were evaluated in an eye-tracking psycholinguistic experiment: 24 children with DLD (average age = 7.8 years, age range = 4.6-12.6), 24 children with the same chronological age (average age = 7.8 years, age range = 4.6-12.2), 24 children with the same linguistic level (average age = 6.8 years, age range = 4.6-9.4) and 24 adults (average age = 22.5 years, age range = 18-30).
OUTCOMES & RESULTS: The empirical data show that, despite some differences, bilingual children with and without DLD can comprehend Spanish prepositions and prepositional locutions under the current experimental conditions.
CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS: Our results suggest that the capacity of bilingual children with DLD to comprehend Spanish prepositions and prepositional locutions in real time and within simple sentence structures is preserved. What this paper adds What is already known on the subject The empirical literature indicates that children with DLD show important errors in the production of functional words in general, and prepositions in particular. However, unlike other grammatical morphemes (such as clitic pronouns and articles), prepositions have been less studied, and the few existing studies have focused on the dimension of language production, not comprehension. What this paper adds to existing knowledge The present study, composed of two experimental tasks, seeks to determine to what extent the observable difficulty in the linguistic production of prepositions is also present in the comprehension of children with DLD. The empirical results suggest a less atypical comprehension in comparison with our initial hypothesis, and the differences that appear between the two tasks, allow us to formulate a theoretical interpretation regarding the mechanisms of their understanding. Thus far, we are not aware of other studies that have evaluated in real time the comprehension of prepositions and prepositional locutions in parallel. Clinical implications of this study Results suggest the presence of a more preserved comprehension of prepositions and prepositional locutions, at least in real-time experimental conditions (eye-tracking) and in simple sentence structures. A less atypical comprehension raises the possibility of a better prognosis for children with DLD. Working with comprehension of simple sentences and the gradual addition of more difficult grammatical morphemes could help to enhance the comprehension of a growing complex grammar.
背景
功能词,尤其是介词和介词短语,被认为是发育性语言障碍(DLD)儿童面临的最重要困难之一。
目的
研究患有发育性语言障碍(DLD)的双语儿童在简单句子结构中理解不同西班牙语介词和介词短语的能力,例如,“El gato está sobre la mesa/El gato está bajo la mesa”(猫在桌子上/猫在桌子下面)。
方法与步骤
我们使用简单句子结构来减少词汇难度,以便将评估严格聚焦于所研究的语法语素。在一项眼动追踪心理语言学实验中,对总共96名讲西班牙语和加泰罗尼亚语的参与者进行了评估,他们被分为四组:24名患有DLD的儿童(平均年龄 = 7.8岁,年龄范围 = 4.6 - 12.6岁),24名年龄相同的儿童(平均年龄 = 7.8岁,年龄范围 = 4.6 - 12.2岁),24名语言水平相同的儿童(平均年龄 = 6.8岁,年龄范围 = 4.6 - 9.4岁)和24名成年人(平均年龄 = 22.5岁,年龄范围 = 18 - 30岁)。
结果
实证数据表明,尽管存在一些差异,但患有和未患有DLD的双语儿童在当前实验条件下都能够理解西班牙语介词和介词短语。
结论与启示
我们的研究结果表明,患有DLD的双语儿童在实时且在简单句子结构中理解西班牙语介词和介词短语的能力得以保留。本文的新增内容 关于该主题已有的知识 实证文献表明,患有DLD的儿童在功能词的产出上,尤其是介词方面,通常会出现重大错误。然而,与其他语法语素(如附着代词和冠词)不同,介词的研究较少,现有的少数研究集中在语言产出维度,而非理解维度。本文对现有知识的补充 本研究由两项实验任务组成,旨在确定在DLD儿童的理解中,介词语言产出方面可观察到的困难程度究竟如何。实证结果表明,与我们最初的假设相比,理解方面的非典型性较小,并且两项任务之间出现的差异使我们能够对其理解机制进行理论解释。到目前为止,我们尚未发现其他研究同时实时评估介词和介词短语的理解情况。本研究的临床意义 结果表明,至少在实时实验条件(眼动追踪)和简单句子结构中,介词和介词短语的理解能力得到了更多保留。理解方面非典型性较小增加了DLD儿童预后较好的可能性。处理简单句子的理解以及逐渐增加更难的语法语素有助于提高对日益复杂语法的理解。