Bradshaw Aaron W, Bechis Seth K, Cobb Kaitlan D, Friedlander David F, DiPina Thomas, Sur Roger L
Department of Urology. University of California San Diego Health. San Diego. California. USA.
Arch Esp Urol. 2020 Nov;73(9):837-842.
Renal access in percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) may be obtained via a pre-existing nephrostomy tube (NT) tract; however, emergent NTs are not always ideal for subsequent surgery. We sought to determine the rate of NT tract usability and assess factors related to the usability of emergently placed NTs.
A retrospective review was performed of UC San Diego subjects undergoing percutaneous renal surgery between January 2016 and October 2018. Demographics and peri-operative variables were collected. The primary outcome was the usability of NT tract for dilation and instrumentation. "Usable" indicated a tract in which PCNL could be completed; "unusable" indicated lack of dilation and the requirement of additional tract(s) for PCNL.
35 PCNL cases had previous emergently placed NT which were indwelling at time of percutaneous surgery. 51% of these NT tracts (18/35) were deemed usable and dilated for PCNL. No significant difference was seen between usable and unusable NT groups for number of dilated tracts during PCNL (p=0.13), or either the location of indwelling NT (p=0.96) or renal stones (p=0.95). In the usable NT tract cohort PCNL access was via the lower pole 56% of the time, where as when previous NT tracts were deemed unusable, a separate upper-pole access was obtained intra-operatively 53% of the time (p<0.01).
Pre-existing, emergent NTs served a ssufficient PCNL access tracts in over half of recorded cases. Contrary to recently published reports, the utility of pre-existing NTs appears to vary among health systems. Other variables, including the desired location of PCNL appear to directly influence the like lihood of NT tract usability.
经皮肾镜取石术(PCNL)的肾脏入路可通过预先存在的肾造瘘管(NT)通道获得;然而,急诊放置的NT并不总是适合后续手术。我们试图确定NT通道的可用率,并评估与急诊放置的NT可用性相关的因素。
对2016年1月至2018年10月在加州大学圣地亚哥分校接受经皮肾手术的患者进行回顾性研究。收集人口统计学和围手术期变量。主要结局是NT通道用于扩张和器械操作的可用性。“可用”表示可以完成PCNL的通道;“不可用”表示缺乏扩张且PCNL需要额外的通道。
35例PCNL病例先前有急诊放置的NT,在经皮手术时仍留置。这些NT通道中有51%(18/35)被认为可用于PCNL并进行了扩张。在PCNL期间,可用和不可用NT组之间扩张通道的数量(p = 0.13)、留置NT的位置(p = 0.96)或肾结石(p = 0.95)均无显著差异。在可用NT通道队列中,56%的时间PCNL入路通过下极,而当先前的NT通道被认为不可用时,术中53%的时间通过单独的上极入路(p<0.01)。
在超过一半的记录病例中,预先存在的急诊NT为PCNL提供了足够的入路通道。与最近发表的报告相反,预先存在的NT的效用在不同医疗系统中似乎有所不同。其他变量,包括PCNL所需的位置,似乎直接影响NT通道的可用性。