Thiesmeyer Jessica W, Ullmann Timothy M, Stamatiou Alexia T, Limberg Jessica, Stefanova Dessislava, Beninato Toni, Finnerty Brendan M, Vignaud Timothée, Leclerc Julie, Fahey Thomas J, Brunaud Laurent, Mirallie Eric, Zarnegar Rasa
Department of Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York-Presbyterian Hospital, New York.
Department of Oncologic, Digestive, and Endocrine Surgery, Nantes University Hospital, Nantes, France.
JAMA Surg. 2021 Feb 1;156(2):165-171. doi: 10.1001/jamasurg.2020.5011.
Adrenal venous sampling is recommended prior to adrenalectomy for all patients with hyperaldosteronism; however, cross-sectional imaging resolution continues to improve, while the procedure remains invasive and technically difficult. Therefore, certain patients may benefit from advancing straight to surgery.
To determine whether clinical and biochemical resolution varied for patients with primary aldosteronism with unilateral adenomas who underwent adrenal venous sampling vs those who proceeded to surgery based on imaging alone.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Retrospective, international cohort study of patients treated at 3 tertiary medical centers from 2004 to 2019, with a median follow-up of approximately 6 months. A total of 217 patients were consecutively enrolled. Exclusion criteria consisted of unknown postoperative serum aldosterone level and imaging inconsistent with unilateral adenoma with a normal contralateral gland. A total of 125 patients were included in the analysis. Data were analyzed between October 2019 and July 2020.
Adrenal venous sampling performed preoperatively.
The primary outcome measurements were the clinical and biochemical success rates of surgery for the cure of hyperaldosteronism secondary to aldosterone-producing adenoma.
A total of 125 patients were included (45 cross-sectional imaging with adrenal venous sampling and 80 imaging only). The mean (SD) age of the study participants was 50.2 (10.6) years and the cohort was 42.4% female (n = 53). Of those patients for whom race or ethnicity were reported (n = 80), most were White (72.5%). Adrenal venous sampling failure rate was 16.7%, and the imaging concordance rate was 100%. Relevant preoperative variables were similar between groups, except ambulatory systolic blood pressure, which was higher in the imaging-only group (150 mm Hg; interquartile range [IQR], 140-172 mm Hg vs 143 mm Hg, IQR, 130-158 mm Hg; P = .03). Resolution of autonomous aldosterone secretion was attained in 98.8% of imaging-only patients and 95.6% of adrenal venous sampling patients (P = .26). There was no difference in complete clinical success (43.6% [n = 34] vs 42.2% [n = 19]) or partial clinical success (47.4% [n = 37] vs 51.1% [n = 23]; P = .87) between groups. Complete biochemical resolution was similar as well (75.9% [n = 41] vs 84.4% [n = 27]; P = .35). There was no difference in clinical or biochemical cure rates when stratified by age, although complete clinical success rates downtrended in the older cohorts, and sample sizes were small.
Given the improved sensitivity of cross-sectional imaging in detection of adrenal tumors, adrenal venous sampling may be selectively performed in appropriate patients with clearly visualized unilateral adenomas without affecting outcomes. This may facilitate increased access to surgical cure for aldosterone-producing adenomas and will decrease the incidence of morbidities associated with the procedure.
对于所有原发性醛固酮增多症患者,建议在肾上腺切除术前行肾上腺静脉采血;然而,横断面成像分辨率持续提高,而该操作仍然具有侵入性且技术难度大。因此,某些患者可能直接进行手术会受益。
确定接受肾上腺静脉采血的单侧腺瘤所致原发性醛固酮增多症患者与仅基于影像学检查直接进行手术的患者在临床和生化缓解方面是否存在差异。
设计、设置和参与者:对2004年至2019年在3家三级医疗中心接受治疗的患者进行回顾性国际队列研究,中位随访时间约为6个月。共连续纳入217例患者。排除标准包括术后血清醛固酮水平未知以及影像学检查结果与单侧腺瘤且对侧腺体正常不符。共125例患者纳入分析。数据于2019年10月至2020年7月进行分析。
术前进行肾上腺静脉采血。
主要结局指标是手术治疗由醛固酮瘤引起的原发性醛固酮增多症的临床和生化成功率。
共纳入125例患者(45例接受横断面成像及肾上腺静脉采血,80例仅接受成像检查)。研究参与者的平均(标准差)年龄为50.2(10.6)岁,队列中女性占42.4%(n = 53)。在报告了种族或民族的患者中(n = 80),大多数为白人(72.5%)。肾上腺静脉采血失败率为16.7%,成像符合率为100%。除动态收缩压外,两组术前相关变量相似,仅接受成像检查组的动态收缩压更高(150 mmHg;四分位间距[IQR],140 - 172 mmHg对比143 mmHg,IQR,130 - 158 mmHg;P = 0.03)。仅接受成像检查的患者中98.8%实现了自主性醛固酮分泌缓解,接受肾上腺静脉采血的患者中这一比例为95.6%(P = 0.26)。两组在完全临床缓解(43.6% [n = 34]对比42.2% [n = 19])或部分临床缓解(47.4% [n = 37]对比51.1% [n = 23];P = 0.87)方面无差异。完全生化缓解情况也相似(75.9% [n = 41]对比84.4% [n = 27];P = 0.35)。按年龄分层时,临床或生化治愈率无差异,尽管老年队列中的完全临床成功率呈下降趋势,且样本量较小。
鉴于横断面成像在检测肾上腺肿瘤方面的敏感性提高,对于单侧腺瘤清晰可见的合适患者,可选择性地进行肾上腺静脉采血,而不影响治疗效果。这可能有助于增加醛固酮瘤手术治愈的可及性,并降低与该操作相关的发病率。