Chen Austin W, Steffes Matthew J, Laseter Joseph R, Maldonado David R, Ortiz-Declet Victor, Perets Itay, Domb Benjamin G
Boulder Centre for Orthopaedics, 4740 Pearl Pkwy #200A, Boulder, CO 80301, USA.
University of Illinois at Chicago, 1200 W Harrison St., Chicago, IL 60607, USA.
J Hip Preserv Surg. 2020 Aug 2;7(2):322-328. doi: 10.1093/jhps/hnaa023. eCollection 2020 Jul.
The rapid growth of hip preservation has left surgeons following trends based on limited, or even anecdotal, evidence in certain circumstances. A consensus as well as high-level research on how best to manage the iliopsoas is lacking. Arthroscopic treatment of the iliopsoas may be an example of how treatment patterns and trends can shift with limited evidence-based medicine. A cross-sectional survey of 16 high-volume hip preservation surgeons was conducted to gather perspectives and opinions on how and why the arthroscopic management of the iliopsoas has evolved. All participants completed the survey in person and anonymously. Of the surveyed surgeons, the mean career hip preservation volume was 1031.25 cases (250 to >3000) with an average annual volume of 162.08 cases (75-400). Of the surveyed surgeons' caseload, 16.1% involved an iliopsoas tenotomy or fractional lengthening mostly commonly (75%) for recalcitrant internal snapping. Labral repair/reconstruction is performed concomitantly 87.5% of the time. Seventy-five percent of surgeons indicated a decrease in frequency of iliopsoas tenotomy over the course of their practice most commonly (56.3%) because of hip flexion weakness; however, 0% of the surgeons could cite literature evidence to support their practices. poor outcomes in individual practices was the most common (56.3%) source of this complication. Surgeons were less inclined to perform tenotomy on patients with borderline dysplasia (75%) or ligamentous laxity (56.3%).
髋关节保留手术的迅速发展使外科医生在某些情况下只能依据有限甚至是轶事性的证据来追随潮流。目前缺乏关于如何最佳处理髂腰肌的共识以及高级别研究。关节镜下治疗髂腰肌可能是一个例子,说明治疗模式和趋势如何在循证医学证据有限的情况下发生转变。对16位高手术量的髋关节保留外科医生进行了一项横断面调查,以收集他们对关节镜下处理髂腰肌的方式及原因演变的观点和看法。所有参与者均亲自且匿名完成了调查。在接受调查的外科医生中,其职业生涯中髋关节保留手术的平均例数为1031.25例(250至>3000例),平均每年手术量为162.08例(75 - 400例)。在接受调查的外科医生的病例量中,16.1%涉及髂腰肌切断术或部分延长术,最常见的情况(75%)是用于治疗顽固性内弹响。87.5%的情况下会同时进行盂唇修复/重建。75%的外科医生表示,在其执业过程中,髂腰肌切断术的频率最常见(56.3%)是因为髋关节屈曲无力而有所下降;然而,0%的外科医生能引用文献证据来支持他们的做法。个体手术效果不佳是这种并发症最常见(56.3%)的来源。外科医生不太倾向于对边缘性发育不良(75%)或韧带松弛(56.3%)的患者进行切断术。