Shanghai Institute of Geriatrics and Gerontology, Shanghai Key Laboratory of Clinical Geriatrics, Department of Geriatrics, Huadong Hospital, and Research Center of Aging and Medicine, Shanghai Medical College, Fudan University, Shanghai, China,
Zhoujiaqiao Primary Health Service Centre, Shanghai, China.
Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord. 2020;49(4):375-383. doi: 10.1159/000505618. Epub 2020 Nov 11.
Subjective questionnaires used for the diagnosis of pre-mild cognitive impairment (pre-MCI) and conventional criteria for MCI might mainly result in false-positive diagnostic errors. The integrated criteria based on demographically adjusted total and process Z scores on neuropsychological tests have been validated to be sensitive for measuring pre-MCI, MCI, and MCI subtypes. However, the underrepresentativity of Chinese populations and the complexity in some tests limit the use of the established Z scores in the elderly Chinese population.
The aim of this study was to develop a useful Z score calculator to assess individual cognitive performance after adjustment of the scores on each of the neuropsychological tests according to sex, age, and education and to establish preliminary norms for the objective assessment of cognition function in elderly Chinese individuals.
The neuropsychological test battery consists of measures of performance on different cognitive domains, including episodic memory, language, executive function, processing speed, and attention. Data were obtained from 220 clinically cognitively normal Chinese volunteers aged 60 years or older from the cohort of the Shanghai study of health promotion among frail elderly individuals. Regression models were used to investigate the impact of age, education, and sex on test scores. Z scores were estimated for the different scores by subtracting the predicted mean from the raw score and dividing it by the root mean square error term for any given linear regression model.
Preliminary analyses indicated that age, sex, or level of education significantly affected test scores. A series of linear regression models was constructed for all instruments, i.e.: the Trail-Making Test A and B, to assess executive function or attention; the Boston Naming Test and animal list generation, to assess language; delayed free correct responses and the Hopkins Verbal Learning Test-Revised (HVLT-R) recognition, as well as three process scores, i.e., intrusion errors, learning slope, and retroactive interference, from the HVLT-R, to assess memory, by adjusting for the covariates of age, sex, and level of education concurrently. The Z scores on all neuropsychological tests were estimated based on the corresponding regression coefficients.
We constructed a multivariable regression-based normative Z score method for the measurement of cognition among older Chinese individuals in the community. The normative score will be useful for the accurate diagnosis of different subtypes of pre-MCI and MCI after preliminary rapid screening in the community.
用于诊断轻度认知障碍前(pre-MCI)的主观问卷和 MCI 的常规标准可能主要导致假阳性诊断错误。基于神经心理学测试的人口统计学调整后的总和过程 Z 分数的综合标准已被验证为测量 pre-MCI、MCI 和 MCI 亚型的敏感指标。然而,中国人群的代表性不足和一些测试的复杂性限制了已建立的 Z 分数在老年中国人群中的使用。
本研究旨在开发一种有用的 Z 分数计算器,以根据性别、年龄和教育程度调整每个神经心理学测试的分数,从而评估个体认知表现,并为中国老年人认知功能的客观评估建立初步的规范。
神经心理学测试组合包括不同认知领域的表现测量,包括情景记忆、语言、执行功能、处理速度和注意力。数据来自来自上海虚弱老年人健康促进队列的 220 名临床认知正常的 60 岁及以上的中国志愿者。回归模型用于研究年龄、教育和性别对测试分数的影响。通过从原始分数中减去预测平均值并将其除以任何给定线性回归模型的均方根误差项,为不同的分数估计 Z 分数。
初步分析表明,年龄、性别或教育水平显著影响测试分数。为所有仪器构建了一系列线性回归模型,即:连线测试 A 和 B,以评估执行功能或注意力;波士顿命名测试和动物列表生成,以评估语言;延迟自由正确反应和霍普金斯言语学习测试修订版(HVLT-R)的再认,以及 HVLT-R 的三个过程分数,即侵入性错误、学习斜率和逆行干扰,通过同时调整年龄、性别和教育程度的协变量来评估记忆。所有神经心理学测试的 Z 分数都是根据相应的回归系数估计的。
我们构建了一种基于多元回归的社区中老年人认知测量的规范 Z 分数方法。该规范分数将有助于在社区进行初步快速筛选后,准确诊断不同类型的 pre-MCI 和 MCI。