Research Department, Prison Reform Trust, London, UK.
Independent Consultant, Researcher, Writer and Trainer, London, UK.
Crim Behav Ment Health. 2020 Dec;30(6):331-340. doi: 10.1002/cbm.2180. Epub 2020 Nov 13.
Despite its abolition in 2012, the indeterminate sentence of Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP) still casts a long shadow over the justice system. Recall is a growing problem: In June 2020, there were 1,359 recalled IPP prisoners. Research documents the negative mental health implications of initial imprisonment under an IPP sentence; however, little is known about experiences on licence, or post-recall.
To explain how recalled IPP prisoners perceive being on licence, and in prison post-recall, to affect their mental wellbeing.
We draw on 31 interviews with recalled IPP prisoners, conducted for a wider project exploring the high rates of IPP recall.
Three themes emerged: a perpetual state of anxiety about recall and spending additional years behind bars; self-imposed social isolation, both in the community and in prison; and a profound sense of hopelessness. People often feel trapped in an unjust and inevitable cycle of imprisonment, with little faith in a positive future.
The government must make structural changes to stop the revolving door of IPP recall. In the short term, confidential mental health support should be available to people serving IPPs in prison and the community.
尽管 2012 年已废除,但“保护监禁”(IPP)的不确定刑期仍给司法系统留下了深远影响。召回是一个日益严重的问题:2020 年 6 月,有 1359 名被召回的 IPP 囚犯。研究记录了最初根据 IPP 判决入狱对心理健康的负面影响;然而,对于在假释期间或召回后的经历却知之甚少。
解释被召回的 IPP 囚犯如何看待假释期间和召回后的监禁对他们的心理健康的影响。
我们借鉴了 31 名被召回的 IPP 囚犯的访谈,这些访谈是为一个更广泛的项目进行的,该项目旨在探讨 IPP 大量召回的问题。
出现了三个主题:对召回和额外数年监禁的持续焦虑;在社区和监狱中自我强加的社交孤立;以及深深的绝望感。人们常常感到被困在一个不公正和不可避免的监禁循环中,对未来几乎没有信心。
政府必须进行结构性改革,以阻止 IPP 召回的循环。在短期内,应该为在狱中和社区中服刑的 IPP 囚犯提供保密的心理健康支持。